liberapay / liberapay.com

Source code of the recurrent donations platform Liberapay
https://liberapay.com/
1.67k stars 215 forks source link

Creators can't hide how many patrons they have #1760

Open nitorita opened 4 years ago

nitorita commented 4 years ago

Users should be given the ability to hide the Patron count for full privacy

tuxayo commented 4 years ago

One could argue that it's good to always see these info for transparency (income and number of patrons) It would be a de factor public income report which it desirable for something seeking funding publicly. Crowdfunding is about trust.

But I also see some reasons why one would want to hide this. It really depends on the point of view. E.g. if the cost of life [1] of your region is then high potential donors could be deterred to donate due to the high existing amount. It would be an unfair penalty. Considering the funded person/project is already using a much more ethical funding channel than mainstream ones. (a better solution would be communication about where the funding goes and set funding goals)

Would a compromise be to be able to hide the number of patrons and amount on the condition to set a funding goal? (which would be displayed in %). So there would be still some level of transparency. And it's not only about transparency. Goals are also a motivating factor to fund because it tells what the funding is for and how near the goal is. Even without a goal, in my case, I can infer from the income that the funding campaign is taking off and it motivate me to join.

[1] and a high difference between raw income and net income after e.g. retirement, unemployment and health insurance are taken into account.