search

liberapay / liberapay.com

Source code of the recurrent donations platform Liberapay
https://liberapay.com/
1.67k stars 215 forks source link

Implement payin by bank wire #45

Closed Changaco closed 8 years ago

Changaco commented 9 years ago

It's not as convenient as credit cards but the fee is only 0.5% instead of 1.8% + €0.18.

juliencarnot commented 8 years ago

Sorry if this is a stupid question, I haven't researched the issue, but have you considered offering to wire money directly from my bank account to liberapay's account by publishing an IBAN and asking users to reference a key in the description field of the transfer, to reconcile the transfer with a user account and credit its wallet? Might be a good option for a 0% fee (at least for a lot of French/European contributors), even if that means going through the transfer interface of their own bank account and might induce some delay before crediting the wallet. Thanks for your time and great project anyways!

Changaco commented 8 years ago

We can't legally hold our users' money in our own bank account, that's why we go through Mangopay. A zero fee option would be nice, but I think 0.5% is low enough, don't you? :-)

juliencarnot commented 8 years ago

Ok, got it! Nothing beats the "Power of Free", but 0.5% will be nice ! ;-)

Changaco commented 8 years ago

This will be done soon, see #316 for details.

Changaco commented 8 years ago

Deployed! Anyone wants to test it? @juliencarnot?

liberapay-2016-05-16-payin-live

juliencarnot commented 8 years ago

Sure! I checked this morning and did not find it but I can see it now! Will let you know how it went for me!

juliencarnot commented 8 years ago

Went through the process without any problem, but a few remarks:

Maybe it could be a bit clearer on what I should expect next (notification/e-mail once my transfer is received and matched with my LiberaPay account?) and on what I should do if nothing happens within this usual delay. I do see the pending payment in the Wallet page though.

Thanks again for this feature, great job!

Changaco commented 8 years ago

first screen: "bank wire to a Euro account" should be "bank wire from a Euro account"

Why? We don't care where the money comes from, we're just telling the user where they'll have to send it and in which currency.

for each amount option, a different fee is listed, and none equates the 0.585% fee "advertised" on top of the dropdown list, and the fee is higher for €13.09 than for €9.81. A bit confusing.

I know, we're rounding the fee twice and it's throwing things off. I may have a solution but I still have to check it against real data to make sure it's correct (we don't want to end up owing money to MangoPay again).

What if I want to put more than 13.09 € in my wallet?

One step at a time. Eventually we'll add the possibility to transfer an arbitrary amount, but first let's test the feature and take care of #251.

Maybe it could be a bit clearer on what I should expect next (notification/e-mail once my transfer is received and matched with my LiberaPay account?) and on what I should do if nothing happens within this usual delay.

You're right, we should tell users that they'll receive an email when the payment succeeds or fails (unless they've disabled those notifications in their email settings).

juliencarnot commented 8 years ago

Fair enough, it was just my euro-centered user feeling regarding the first message. For the other points, I understand perfectly and again, kudos for rolling this out!

Changaco commented 8 years ago

I've just deployed #323 and reticketed the other issues as #325 and #326.

Changaco commented 8 years ago

@juliencarnot's money has arrived, our first bank wire payin is a success! :-)

juliencarnot commented 8 years ago

\o/

juliencarnot commented 8 years ago

just a glitch: the receipt link leads to a 404 page, both in notification tray and e-mail, they are missing the .html extension.

Changaco commented 8 years ago

Oh, yeah, I didn't put the .html suffix. /o\

Email and notifications are the same, so it's normal that they're both affected. The link on the wallet page is correct.

Changaco commented 8 years ago

Fix in #328.