search

mastodon / mastodon

Your self-hosted, globally interconnected microblogging community
https://joinmastodon.org
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
46.93k stars 6.94k forks source link

Make unread counter in title opt-in #12211

Open trwnh opened 4 years ago

trwnh commented 4 years ago

11560 added a counter of unread notifications to the page title. This behavior should be opt-in.

joyeusenoelle commented 4 years ago

A note in support of this. As I said here, when I first joined Mastodon in April 2017 having "unread notifications" in the window title was considered an antipattern and many users were vocal about appreciating its absence. This behavior should be opt-out at minimum and optimally should be opt-in.

ashquarky commented 4 years ago

+1 for having this be optional. I find it extremely difficult to ignore counters from certain apps/websites, and while I can tough it out it, it's much easier for me to manage where my attention is going if I can disable this kind of thing.

elaine-jackson commented 4 years ago

Coming from sites like Facebook and Twitter, I would expect this behavior? Perhaps make it opt-out, or ask them in the user onboarding process (the welcome to Mastodon tutorial). To elaborate I would expect this behavior and not know there was an option to enable it.

trwnh commented 4 years ago

Coming from sites like Facebook and Twitter, I would expect this behavior?

I would argue that Mastodon should not be like Facebook or Twitter. Those sites also have algorithmic feeds and advertisements. Expected behavior of other products shouldn't be copied blindly.

elaine-jackson commented 4 years ago

I agree we shouldn’t copy blindly. We should consider what philosophical trade offs we are willing to make to increase adoption.

On Mon, Oct 28, 2019 at 1:30 AM, trwnh notifications@github.com wrote:

Coming from sites like Facebook and Twitter, I would expect this behavior?

I would argue that Mastodon should not be like Facebook or Twitter. Those sites also have algorithmic feeds and advertisements. Expected behavior of other products shouldn't be copied blindly.

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.

wolfpurplemoon commented 4 years ago

When it first started it was very unclear what it was notifying about, in a multi column layout it could be something new in any of the columns. If I want to be instantly notified about notifications there is already the nice bloop sound

harrybailey commented 1 year ago

Looks like since 2019 this change has both been merged / added and then removed again.

So this issues would now be a suggestion, or even closed.