search

matrix-hacks / matrix-puppet-facebook

a puppetted facebook bridge
98 stars 21 forks source link

No way to start conversations with Facebook users #2

Open tfreedman opened 7 years ago

tfreedman commented 7 years ago

If someone on facebook messages me, I'll be dropped into a room properly on matrix. However, there's no way to get a list of all my friends or anything, if I want to start a conversation with someone who I don't have a currently open window with in matrix.

kfatehi commented 7 years ago

That's true. Doing it this way was much easier and minimalist in that only those that message you would cause a room to be created, rather than to create rooms for everyone on your list (or in your contacts book, in the case of iMessage, for example), many of whom do not message you.

That said I think there should be a way to initiate without having to go to the third party client (e.g. facebook.com or iMessage). One way could be through bang commands in a bot room. For example we can do something like this, where to start talking to you I can tell facebookbot the following:

!chat tfreedman

and then this will cause the bridge code to look for a contact with that name.

if multiple matches, have me select one by entering the number of the correct match (1,2,3,)

if no matches, let me know.

once matched, create the room, create the ghost user in that room, and allow communication..

thoughts? can you think of a better way?

kfatehi commented 7 years ago

ping @AndrewJDR

tfreedman commented 7 years ago

There's a better way, which is what software like Bitlbee does - it creates a room called Facebook, and drops all of your contacts in there. There's no actual talking in the room, but you can right click a name and start PMing that person.

kfatehi commented 7 years ago

That's a great solution. I'd like such a special room for having status messages like https://github.com/AndrewJDR/matrix-puppet-bridge/issues/3 and maybe even configuration type stuff. Most of the logic can be implemented generally in https://github.com/AndrewJDR/matrix-puppet-bridge and then the bridges can be modified to take advantage of it by syncing users from the 3rd party side.

kfatehi commented 7 years ago

support for this has been merged into the develop branch for now https://github.com/matrix-hacks/matrix-puppet-bridge/pull/11

kfatehi commented 7 years ago

Solution is in master. Starting conversations from the users created in the room needs to be tested, however, and then we can close this issue.

babolivier commented 6 years ago

Hey there, I recently installed the bridge from master, and although it created me a room with all of my contacts in there, I can't initiate a conversation with one of them by just PMing them. If I open a direct chat in Riot with one of them, it will invite the Facebook contact in it, who will never join, and no message will pass through the bridge. The only log I can see from when I tell Riot to create the direct chat room is

EventTimelineSet.addLiveEvent: ignoring duplicate event [...]

which happens at the room creation.

JeffAlyanak commented 5 years ago

Hey there, I recently installed the bridge from master, and although it created me a room with all of my contacts in there, I can't initiate a conversation with one of them by just PMing them. If I open a direct chat in Riot with one of them, it will invite the Facebook contact in it, who will never join, and no message will pass through the bridge. The only log I can see from when I tell Riot to create the direct chat room is

EventTimelineSet.addLiveEvent: ignoring duplicate event [...]

which happens at the room creation.

I can confirm identical behaviour.

Have you found any workarounds for that?

stacyharper commented 5 years ago

Got exactly the same thing here.

stacyharper commented 5 years ago

And the room created when someone initiate the conversation looks like "Unnamed Room (#facebook_1000071XXXXXXX:synapse.XXXX.XX)"

Is this normal ?