search

mcMMO-Dev / mcMMO

The RPG Lover's Mod!
https://mcmmo.org
GNU General Public License v3.0
986 stars 855 forks source link

Suggestion: Spawn silverfish as fishing trap #3573

Open ghost opened 5 years ago

ghost commented 5 years ago

I'd like fishing to occasionally spawn a silverfish because it's a trap that can be fought off, rather than instantly hurting the player. This would benefit servers that don't allow AFK fishing because when players are actively fishing they can fight off the silverfish, but when players AFK fish they will eventually be killed by them.

Zappa2510 commented 5 years ago

well thats what the tnt and potions are for, plus the kraken. most afk farms ive seen you have to spam click and when that happens it summons the kraken and kills them.

ghost commented 5 years ago

@Zappa2510 I would like more traps, is what I'm saying. Or better traps. Silverfish, being a mob, can be ran away from or strategically fought. Tnt on the other hand just blows up. The kraken is also overkill - loud, annoying, affects regular players with false positives. An occasional trap that would eventually kill the player if left unattended (like silverfish) would be a calmer solution.

Zappa2510 commented 5 years ago

true...but most ive seen people who try to abuse afk fishing are usually alone and closed up in a small location.

Romaq commented 5 years ago

We've not seen the kraken using a tool like AutoClick on a note-block with a half-second pause between clicks. I'm not clear if it's long enough it doesn't trigger the kraken anyway, or why it never spawned. And while I'm the server-op, a Man's Gotta Do What a Man's Gotta Do, and I'm Gonna Do what my wife tells me to... so I had to pull out the traps. :( But if my wife would let me have them in, pulling up a silver-fish as a trap would help make sure people are not AFK without at least an ear out.

Zappa2510 commented 5 years ago

only time the kraken comes out if you hold down the mouse button and it spams it. normal fishing wont trigger it. if you wait for the fish to get the line then pull it in and recast it wont summon the kraken.

nossr50 commented 5 years ago

I could probably implement a less death oriented solution to prevent afk fishing

mrfloris commented 5 years ago

I could probably implement a less death oriented solution to prevent afk fishing

A command to temp ban them would be great :) Screw auto fishers, don't play the game pls if you aren't actually there playing,.. heck - make it a perm ban.

nossr50 commented 5 years ago

I could probably put something in to alert admins to auto-fishing

Romaq commented 5 years ago

FYI per https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/mapping-and-modding-java-edition/minecraft-mods/1289421-autofish-mod-for-minecraft-1-12-2

Quote: I am a server administrator and would like to disable this mod on my server. How can I do this? This mod supports ClientPermissions. Follow the instructions and add it to your server to prevent players from using the mod. /Quote

Client Permissions would allow you to forbid this AFK fishing tool (and various other LiteLoader mod client mods supporting Client Permissions) to simply not work on the server. Other mods may be possible, and harder to detect depending on how the mod was coded, but NOT allowing them where possible in the server itself is a good start.

I do support the "catch AFK Fishers with mcMMO", and the server /op sets the server rules others should abide by. But as mentioned before, my wife and I make use of AFK fishing on our server as part of the game. On HermitCraft, we note they also make heavy use of AFK fishing, so the option to allow AFK fishing in the .config if allowed on the server is strongly supported as well.

ghost commented 5 years ago

FYI per https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/mapping-and-modding-java-edition/minecraft-mods/1289421-autofish-mod-for-minecraft-1-12-2

Quote: I am a server administrator and would like to disable this mod on my server. How can I do this? This mod supports ClientPermissions. Follow the instructions and add it to your server to prevent players from using the mod. /Quote

Client Permissions would allow you to forbid this AFK fishing tool (and various other LiteLoader mod client mods supporting Client Permissions) to simply not work on the server. Other mods may be possible, and harder to detect depending on how the mod was coded, but NOT allowing them where possible in the server itself is a good start.

I do support the "catch AFK Fishers with mcMMO", and the server /op sets the server rules others should abide by. But as mentioned before, my wife and I make use of AFK fishing on our server as part of the game. On HermitCraft, we note they also make heavy use of AFK fishing, so the option to allow AFK fishing in the .config if allowed on the server is strongly supported as well.

That plugin hasn't been updated since 1.8.

nossr50 commented 5 years ago

@Romaq If we add in measures to combat AFK fishing they will be configurable (aka you can turn them off or tweak them).