Inconsistency of Specification and Repository

modelica / ssp-ls-traceability

Prototyping of an SSP Traceability Layered Standard

Other

11 stars 4 forks source link

Inconsistency of Specification and Repository #41

Closed mdeppe closed 1 year ago

mdeppe commented 3 years ago

When looking at the repo and the specification there is a high inconsistency in regards to the XML schemas. It is really unclear what it is all about and I'm getting confused:

Specification is about STMD and SRMD
Example is using SMMD
Repository contains schemas for SPMD, SMMD, STMD, SRMD

So what is the role of SMMD and SPMD?

ClemensLinnhoff commented 1 year ago

I just stumbled across the same problems. Why was this issue closed? There are still SMMD files in the example. The schema file referenced in those files is "../../../SMMD.xsd", which does not exist. And I have the same question: What is the difference between SRMD and SMMD? And are there any examples of correct SRMD files?

This is linked to #51 which was also prematurely closed. I am still unable to validate the schema of an SRMD file.

pmai commented 1 year ago

This issue was about SMMD still being part of the available schemas, which has since been removed, since ongoing maintenance of SMMD is no longer being pursued. The TraceabilityDemo examples still uses SMMD, but just as another format, like FMUs, which are not defined by the spec. The example is also currently in the process of being revamped and moved to the SSPTraceabilityExamples repo, to clarify this even further. Note that SSP Traceability supports any kind of meta-data formats, with SRMD just being one that is supplied by the spec itself.

ClemensLinnhoff commented 1 year ago

It is still quite confusing. So I am really looking forward to the examples!