moinejf / abc2svg

project moved to https://chiselapp.com/user/moinejf/repository/abc2svg
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
48 stars 7 forks source link

Use the xml exported by musescore to generate an abc file prompt: bad tie #125

Closed roinheart closed 1 year ago

roinheart commented 1 year ago

musescore xml: `

A 4 2 1 eighth up begin G 4 2 1 eighth up end E 4 2 1 eighth up begin D 4 2 1 eighth up end 2 1 eighth E 4 1 1 16th up begin begin D 4 1 1 16th up end end

` image

abc file: AG ED z E/-D/ image

moinejf commented 1 year ago

This is not a ABC nor a abc2svg problem. In the ABC standard, '-' is a tie, and in music, a tie is a curved line that makes the duration of a note to be extended by the duration of the next note. In all cases both notes must be at the same pitch. So, E/-D/ is wrong.

In the upper image, there is a slur, so, the generated ABC should have been: AG ED z(E/D/ | E6)

roinheart commented 1 year ago

Thanks moinejf!