search

mongoose-os-apps / shelly-homekit

Apple HomeKit firmware for Shelly's
Other
1.84k stars 130 forks source link

Unable to install HomeKit after upgrading to 1.4.0 firmware #1428

Closed johnmrichey closed 3 months ago

johnmrichey commented 4 months ago

I have tried all the methods for installing HomeKit and they all fail. I am also unable to go back to an older firmware which I posted about on the Shelly Forum.

Any suggestion please to get HomeKit installed on Shelly 1 Plus running firmware 1.4.0?

https://community.shelly.cloud/topic/1852-unable-to-downgrade-to-other-firmware-after-updating-to-version-140/#comment-8946

johnmrichey commented 3 months ago

I am unable to get the Shelly back to an older version firmware after updating to 1.4.0. Any suggestion how to do this please as I have tried everything mentioned out there.

markirb commented 3 months ago

I can only tell from experience some weeks ago on 1.4.0b on Plus2PM:

Stock: 1.4.0b downgrade to 1.3.3 was possible 1.4.0b to Shelly-HomeKit fails because of rootfs size but should not break anything.

Shelly-HomeKit: Revert to 1.4.0b fails correctly and expectedly due to app size but does not break anything.

I do not know yet how Shelly-HomeKit should support the partition size change:

The best thing would be to implement the migration like Shelly does. But this is tedious work, as it has to work with the failsafe OTA mechanism.

Also it is tedious for everybody to revert to 1.3.3 then upgrade to 1.4.0 then flash Shelly-HomeKit with new partition sizes variant.

It could also be done with a split for two different partition layouts but that is not nice for users.

johnmrichey commented 3 months ago

I was not able to ever migrate to HomeKit, so I don't believe failing to downgrade to 1.3.3 has anything to do with trying to migrate to HomeKit.

Regardless I am still not able to downgrade after updating to 1.4.0 on the 1P Shelly.

markirb commented 3 months ago

You need to downgrade to 1.3.3 do you have that version? What is the error message?

johnmrichey commented 3 months ago

Do you have the zip or the URL please?

mtran83 commented 3 months ago

I'm also facing the same issue after updating to FW v1.4.0

Any way of downgrading the firmware?

johnmrichey commented 3 months ago

The Shelly forum says it's not possible to downgrade from 1.4.0. Nope no way was the last comment on my post.

rmmmrm commented 3 months ago

@johnmrichey contact shelly suport and they send the zip. It worked for me for all my shelly's ony the shelly plus 1 is not working because i cannot flash the shelly-homekit

rmmmrm commented 3 months ago

@johnmrichey @mtran83 Down here you have the 1.3.3 firmware for these shelly models Regards

PlusI4-1.3.3.zip Plus1-1.3.3.zip PlusHT-1.3.3.zip Plus2PM-1.3.3.zip

mtran83 commented 3 months ago

thanks @rmmmrm

How are you updating these firmware using the above shared zip files? Via the Shelly Web UI?

rmmmrm commented 3 months ago

Hello @mtran83 Yes via shelly MzWimiwgXQGsAaRx_SjTV3i5rXnf2KN9Xg

ivofernandespt commented 3 months ago

@johnmrichey @mtran83 Down here you have the 1.3.3 firmware for these shelly models Regards

PlusI4-1.3.3.zip Plus1-1.3.3.zip PlusHT-1.3.3.zip Plus2PM-1.3.3.zip

Anyone have this version for Plus 1PM?

markirb commented 3 months ago

http://rojer.me/files/shelly/stock/1.3.3/