mpi-forum / mpi-issues

Tickets for the MPI Forum
http://www.mpi-forum.org/
67 stars 8 forks source link

Bindings - Export "outcome is as if..." code fragments as proper examples #623

Closed wesbland closed 1 year ago

wesbland commented 2 years ago

Problem

Some codes are presented in the document as example implementations but not in example format. It is usually the case for the purpose of presenting what the function output should look like, and is preceded by a sentence such as "The outcome is as if ..."

Also, how such codes are presented are not coherent throughout the whole document. In collective: one or two isolated lines of codes In topology: functional complete pseudo code

Proposal

Export these fragment of codes as proper examples

Changes to the Text

Export these fragment of codes as proper examples

Impact on Implementations

Should be none

Impact on Users

Should be none

wesbland commented 1 year ago

This wasn't read at the December 2022 meeting. The last opportunity for MPI 4.1 is to have it ready at the March 2022 meeting (and it needs to "pass" the reading).

@puribangalore Are you (or is someone else) planning to push this forward or should we move it out of the plan for MPI 4.1?

RolfRabenseifner commented 1 year ago

I tried to find "as if" (and also "outcome" and "behave") in MPI-4.0 Chapter 19:

@wesbland Therefore, I recommend to close this issue as complete.