nus-cs2113-AY2425S1 / forum

3 stars 0 forks source link

tp PE: Dev Team Referenced Prof, would like to clarify if accurate #50

Open DarkDragoon2002 opened 4 days ago

DarkDragoon2002 commented 4 days ago

Hi Prof, would like to check and clarify to see if you said the following below to team W10-2 as they quoted you in their Dev Response.

Their app in it's current state does not allow for adding of custom entries and only allows additions that match a pre-defined list.

I believe it is not enough functionality for tp requirements and even if it is, as a CEG student who has applied for SEP (their target user as identified in their DG) not having custom entry capabilities is very debilitating. In fact most of my peers mapped mods outside the small selection provided. Hence, I would think this is an important part that should be included. They also only mentioned this limitation in their FAQs in their UGs and not under the add command section.

They have quoted you in their defense to term this as severity.Low and type.NotInResponse from severity.High. Would just like to confirm if what they stated was true and some guidance on this matter. Thanks!

Screenshots for your reference. image

image

okkhoy commented 4 days ago

Please respond based on the scope the team has decided and your perception. My response to the team is based on what was explained to me and what I understood; your response should be based on your perception/evaluation.