open-contracting / standard

Documentation of the Open Contracting Data Standard (OCDS)
http://standard.open-contracting.org/
Other
139 stars 46 forks source link

Create field for congressional or legislative district #353

Closed agm3dc closed 8 years ago

agm3dc commented 8 years ago

There appears to be no clear field that could pertain to congressional or legislative district. Such a field could be included in: award.suppliers.address; buyer.address; tender.tenderers.address; tender.procuringEntity.address

timgdavies commented 8 years ago

Is the intention of this:

Can you give some examples of how this would be used, or cases where there is demand for it?

agm3dc commented 8 years ago

I've just been informed that there's a likely project location extension upcoming. I would move for the congressional district field to be included under that project location.

The most clear-cut use case would be determining geographic beneficiaries of government procurement. Imagine a map that shows wealthy congressional districts in the US receiving far higher procurement dollars than the poor districts next door.

I could also see an interest in having a congressional field for award.suppliers.address. But it wouldn't be as strong an argument as a congressional location extension for project.

Thx

timgdavies commented 8 years ago

Yes - the location extension (new format) can be found here

This includes a deliveryLocation at the item level which can have a gazetteer based classification of locations (e.g. treating list of congressional districts as a gazetteer) which would be appropriate for this.

The same location object could also be attached to suppliers - although I would assume in most cases the supplier district could be worked out by geocoding their address, so it might not be necessary to explicitly include this in the data (at least, in so far as the core standard is concerned - local implementation would be free to do this).

timgdavies commented 8 years ago

@agm3dc Hoping the location extension covers what you need.

Closing this issue for now - but do re-open if you've not found you can do what you need with location extension.