search

opengeospatial / ets-cat30

OGC Catalogue 3.0 Conformance Test Suite
Other
0 stars 6 forks source link

Correct version of the specification #20

Closed bermud closed 8 years ago

bermud commented 8 years ago

When the development of the test started the following specifications were used:

The above references are the ones we used in the description of the test (welcome page).

I see we have now:

Is the latest revision of the test aligned with the latest revision of the standard?

And, we need to confirm that the test is implementing the following "implementable" standard: OGC Catalogue Services 3.0 Specification - HTTP Protocol Binding

rjmartell commented 8 years ago

The last (pre-)release occurred in Oct 2015 and there have been no commits since. The final OGC specifications were approved several months later, so the tests may not be aligned with these depending on how many changes accrued between 12-176r5 (last revision: 2014-12-02) and 12-176r7 (approved: 2016-02-29) . A comparison should reveal this and indicate which changes--if any--are required to achieve alignment.

The test suite does indeed target the HTTP binding.

bermud commented 8 years ago

@Keshav, please compare this spec http://docs.opengeospatial.org/is/12-176r7/12-176r7.html with the current test.

keshavnangare commented 8 years ago

We have compared both specification document given below:

  1. http://docs.opengeospatial.org/is/12-176r7/12-176r7.html
  2. 12-176r6_OGC_Catalogue_Services_3.0Specification-_HTTP_Protocol_Binding.docx

The latest updated document(12-176r7) contains the same Test/ Requirements in the old spec document(12-176r6).

We have compared the tests of the two conformance classes 1. Basic-Catalogue 2. OpenSearch, so both class contains the same tests.

bermud commented 8 years ago

@keshav-nangare, Thank you!