opensourceantibiotics / murligase

Everything to do with the Mur Ligase Project
29 stars 6 forks source link

Mur Ligase Meeting September 2023  #102

Open Yuhang-CADD opened 1 year ago

Yuhang-CADD commented 1 year ago

Date: Sep 12th 2023 Time: 2pm UK time other timezones

Place: https://ucl.zoom.us/j/91379419977

Recording: https://youtu.be/XrB8R_32bB0?si=ySufgClfVFvOCbkZ

Previous Meeting: #101 Who can come?: Anyone. No need to say anything unless you'd like to.

Apologies:

Decks: Please @opensourceantibiotics/murligase remember that if you share slides/info, to drag and drop those into a comment on this page, below. Very easy and saves @mattodd having to pester you.

Agenda:

Key things today are:

i) Multi-targeting compounds identified from Warwick and Atomwise collections. We need a crystal structure of one or more of these multi-targeting hits to pursue grant funding.

ii) Yuhang's "efflux-proof" amine derivative of the AZ compound was found to bind by SPR, but gave no activity vs wt bacteria (data on wiki and a summary of data in #96. Need to complete checks of enzymatic activity of these compounds, to verify the design is OK in terms of enzyme inhibition. (Still awaiting for the IC50 values)

iii) When would the rest of the Warwick Enamine collection be scheduled for evaluation in the enzymatic assay?

iv) Shall we suggest a booking & tracking system where people can book period slots for fresh sample testing (easy to arrange shipment and avoid sample deterioration) and see the results remotely in real time? (e.g., we could set it up on google sheet as a live document.)

(please add if you'd like to prioritise anything)

1) Multi-targeting Compounds from the Warwick/NEU Enamine Collection

Crystallography at The University of Kansas: J06 (Z2010503124) had also been sent to Uni Kansas (Scott Lovell, via Bart).

2) Multi-targeting Elaborated Fragments from Diamond Fragment Screen

3) Atomwise Hits

4) Variants of AZ Compounds

5) New Protein Structures

The PDB list has been updated with the new, recent structures: 8EGM, 8EGN, 8DOF, 8DP2, 8EWA. Jan Abendroth has completed the final SSGCID X-ray collection for MurC, with the series of three AZ compounds bound to this protein. In the two protein chains, the piperidine moiety of the ligand is in two different conformations. Jan's assumption is that the conformation in chain B is the native one, since it does not involve interaction with a symmetry mate. Thank you Jan!

6) De Novo Computational Modelling

7) Other Potential Starting Points

8) CC4CARB Proposal (#93)

Following discussions between @eyermanncj @Yuhang-CADD and @mattodd a proposal is being written for CC4CARBfunding to help with chemistry aimed at exploring more potential binding interactions with the Murs, specifically areas where phosphates normally bind.

9) Misc/AOB

Last time @AJLloyd105 reported on the evaluation, enzymatically, of "double-headed" compounds containing uridine and ATP binders: . These were found to be binders and will be investigated further (need to upload deck). @AJLloyd105 to update as appropriate.

10) List of any Raw Data That Needs Posting Online

Suitable locations: ideally an electronic lab notebook, another suitable repository (Zenodo, Figshare) or Github itself.

11) Mothballs (if no actions then these need to be linked in wiki and closed)

Next Meeting

Oct 10th 2pm UK time

L'esprit de l'escalier

If you'd like to follow up after the meeting, please comment below. You can also email, but please be clear if anything in the email should not be public domain - the default is always open.

yiwei905 commented 1 year ago

MurE inhibition data for multitargeting hits sent on the 23rd May and 25th July 2023, including synthesised derivatives of compounds AW53 by @yiwei905, AW9 by @EveCarter, as well as derivatives of the multitargeting compounds bought from Enamine, and 2 competition compounds by @edwintse as summarised here.

MurD inhibition data +structures were also attached: P. aeruginosa MurD inhibition.pdf

Screenshot 2023-09-12 at 20 15 14 Screenshot 2023-09-12 at 20 15 26 Screenshot 2023-09-12 at 20 15 37 Screenshot 2023-09-12 at 20 15 52

P. aeruginosa MurE Inhibition Data of Multitargeting Hits.pdf P. aeruginosa MurE Inhibition Data of Multitargeting Hits.docx

P. aeruginosa MurD inhibition data.docx

bartrum commented 1 year ago

Hi All, I apologize as I can't make this time today due to needing to commute into lab today for experiments. However, fresh MurD protein for Ab has been shipped to our crystallization group in Kansas for cocrystallization. It looks like the Ps MurD prep failed and will be tried again. I will check the notes if there is any requests for SSGCID. Thanks Bart Staker

On Tue, Sep 12, 2023 at 5:26 AM yiwei905 @.***> wrote:

MurE inhibition data for multitargeting hits sent on the 23rd May and 25th July 2023, including synthesised derivatives of compounds AW53 by @yiwei905 https://github.com/yiwei905, AW9 by @EveCarter https://github.com/EveCarter, as well as derivatives of the multitargeting compounds bought from Enamine, and 2 competition compounds by @edwintse https://github.com/edwintse as summarised here https://github.com/opensourceantibiotics/murligase/issues/98. [image: Screenshot 2023-09-12 at 20 15 14] https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/115191180/267324676-831d4f8f-01f4-499f-89f0-4f9b88df6c33.png [image: Screenshot 2023-09-12 at 20 15 26] https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/115191180/267324935-2187ee58-c864-4adf-94d0-ef0ed62b58a9.png [image: Screenshot 2023-09-12 at 20 15 37] https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/115191180/267324971-ca4a380a-79e9-4389-9700-70c9dbbfa10f.png [image: Screenshot 2023-09-12 at 20 15 52] https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/115191180/267324794-54ff84ad-225e-4c0d-859b-8e2bf250ef31.png

P. aeruginosa MurE Inhibition Data of Multitargeting Hits.pdf https://github.com/opensourceantibiotics/murligase/files/12586208/P.aeruginosa.MurE.Inhibition.Data.of.Multitargeting.Hits.pdf P. aeruginosa MurE Inhibition Data of Multitargeting Hits.docx https://github.com/opensourceantibiotics/murligase/files/12586257/P.aeruginosa.MurE.Inhibition.Data.of.Multitargeting.Hits.docx

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/opensourceantibiotics/murligase/issues/102#issuecomment-1715627868, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABKGBLR3AJUTMSZV2W5DM6DX2BIIXANCNFSM6AAAAAA4QIIRLA . You are receiving this because you are on a team that was mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

Yuhang-CADD commented 1 year ago

1. Amine Building Block (Synthetic Explorations)

Screenshot 2023-09-12 at 13 59 45

2. Guanidinium Reagent Synthesis

Screenshot 2023-09-12 at 13 58 11
AJLloyd105 commented 1 year ago

230823 to 080923 data compilation Yiwei OSA MurD E Cand F data 2.pptx

AJLloyd105 commented 1 year ago

Dear All, Please find attached screening data vs P. aeruginosa MurC, D, E and F for Yiwei's OSA (Atomwise and related) compounds sent 230523 and 250723 (previous comment).

mattodd commented 1 year ago

Very good multitargeting data on these compounds, wow.

phraenquex commented 1 year ago

Indeed... terrific!

phraenquex commented 1 year ago

@mattodd if these are structurally related, is it time to do an extensive SAR scan? Warren (@waztom) has his CAR system working increasingly smoothly, they put 500 crudes into crystals last month; so if these MurCDEF assays can be set up to run as panel, it seems it's worth a try?
Because presumably the challenge of getting to Real Potency for all will need a Lot Of Data, Quickly.

chrisdowson1 commented 1 year ago

Worth a follow up conversation regarding resource for the chemistry and the assays - agree scale will help. Laura currently working on crystals for the current set

Catch up early next week? BW. Chris

Sent from Outlook for iOShttps://aka.ms/o0ukef


From: Frank von Delft @.> Sent: Tuesday, September 19, 2023 6:48:20 AM To: opensourceantibiotics/murligase @.> Cc: Dowson, Christopher @.>; Mention @.> Subject: Re: [opensourceantibiotics/murligase] Mur Ligase Meeting September 2023 (Issue #102)

@mattoddhttps://github.com/mattodd if these are structurally related, is it time to do an extensive SAR scan? Warren @.***https://github.com/Waztom) has his CAR system working increasingly smoothly, they put 500 crudes into crystals last month; so if these MurCDEF assays can be set up to run as panel, it seems it's worth a try? Because presumably the challenge of getting to Real Potency for all will need a Lot Of Data, Quickly.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/opensourceantibiotics/murligase/issues/102#issuecomment-1724866702, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ALNDKBMY2JAEQPZWWXB4A3TX3EW2JANCNFSM6AAAAAA4QIIRLA. You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

AJLloyd105 commented 1 year ago

From the multi-targeting perspective, there are a couple of interesting papers that came out in 2006 and 2007 from the Infectious Diseases Division of Wyeth (before it was phagocytosed by Pfizer). The papers relate to a series of compounds based upon pulvinone. These compounds had activity vs E. coli MurA, B, C and D with IC50 values (quoted in ug/ml but recalculated as uM) of 2.25, 2.25, 4.5 and 13.5 uM (recalculated from Antane et al. (2006). Bioorg Chem Lett, 16, 176-180). The 2007 paper (Mansour et al (2007) ChemMedChem 2, 1414-1417) followed this up, with a crystal structure of one of these molecules in the active site of E. coli MurB ((PDB 2Q85) where the compound was in the substrate binding site) and MIC data, which showed activity vs S. aureus (4 to 64 ug/ml depending on compound) and E. coli (2 to 16 ug/ml), exciting although enthusiasm is curbed a bit on excavation of the text to reveal the E. coli strain (unrecorded) was “outer-membrane permeable”). The point I am trying to get to, is that as with the pulvinone molecules that may well be recognised for targeting the uridine binding site of MurA to D, I am wondering if the compounds I have found to have MurC to F activity might by analogy be active vs MurB? This conjecture is somewhat encouraged by the fact that (as I am given to understand) the Atomwise compound set and derivatives thereof do not target the ATP pocket of Mur ligases. It’s an easy albeit time-consuming experiment. Antane et al (2006) Bioorg Med Chem Lett 16, 176-180.pdf Mansour et al (2007) ChemMedCHem 2, 1414-1417.pdf