search

openstreetmap / id-tagging-schema

🆔🏷 The presets and other tagging data used by the iD editor
ISC License
160 stars 164 forks source link

Ticket validator icon is confusing #1387

Open dokutan opened 1 week ago

dokutan commented 1 week ago

Describe the bug The icon for amenity=ticket_validator is the generic vending machine icon (temaki-vending_machine). This is confusing, as ticket validators aren't vending machines, but are commonly placed near transit ticket and other (sometimes generic) vending machines.

To Reproduce Place a ticket validator next to a vending machine.

Expected behavior

  1. Reuse the existing ticket vending machine icon (temaki-vending_tickets) for ticket validators, this is not ideal but in my opinion still better than the current icon, or
  2. Add a new icon for ticket validators.
matkoniecz commented 1 week ago

Reuse the existing ticket vending machine icon (temaki-vending_tickets) for ticket validators, this is not ideal but in my opinion still better than the current icon, or

would reduce confusion with generic vending machine, increase confusion with machine selling tickets, not sure which is worse

trivial to change - I did it in change ticket_validator icon to ticket #1388 - you can test it there and follow "Checklist and Test-Documentation Template" to make it more likely to merge

if on testing it is not great idea - please comment there so I can close the PR