overhangio / tutor

The Docker-based Open edX distribution designed for peace of mind
https://docs.tutor.overhang.io/
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
913 stars 434 forks source link

Grade Download Needed #143

Closed frohro closed 5 years ago

frohro commented 5 years ago

I have been using tutor with good results this school year in a blended learning environment. I am getting to the point where I think the analytics package would be very nice to have. The things I see as being really helpful are:

Any advice would be welcome!

Thanks, Rob

regisb commented 5 years ago

@frohro I agree that Insights would be a great addition. However, I estimate that integrating Insights into Tutor is going to take ~1 month work. This is the reason why I am looking for sponsors for this effort. (see issue #58)

However, I'm not quite sure the feature you need is related to Insights. From my understanding, all we need is to activate the ENABLE_GRADE_DOWNLOADS feature. Can you try to add ENABLE_GRADE_DOWNLOADS: true to the FEATURES entry in lms.env.json?

frohro commented 5 years ago

Thanks Regis! I edited the file in these two locations, but didn't change the one in templaces, and wow! I got the options I need for downloading grades! See the screenshot below: image Thank you so much!!

I have noticed that when I actually try to download the grades, it claims to be doing that, but the grades do not appear as they do on edunext.co. Some things seem to work like downloading a csv of the certificates, but not the grades. See this screenshot: image I tried it on the same course with edunext.co and it claims to have finished, but there is no link at the bottom of the tutor edX, while there is in the edunext.co edX.

I'm only a professor, and not in control of any budgets or even with much if any influence with anyone who might have funding for a month's work, but if I did, I think being able to look at learner engagement would be worth it. I'm planning to work on selling others here at the university on the open edX platform for blended learning. The analytics features would really help with that, but if something miraculous happens, and I am able to sell it in such a way that there is actually some funding available, I'll let you know. In the meantime, I am happy to help with testing the platform for you. I'm going to have to rely on student self reporting of their engagement, and trying to encourage it with quizzes, homework, and making the best content I can.

Again, thanks for the grade download feature. Hopefully I can figure out what is the problem with it is. Rob

frohro commented 5 years ago

I had a problem with issue #136. I'm hoping it may be my problem with not actually being able to download the grades. I noted that I need to modify all the below files, for the fix to not disappear, but it doesn't appear to have solved that issue. Here are the files I modified: /home/frohro/openedx-docker/deploy/env/openedx/lms.env.json /home/frohro/openedx-docker/deploy/env/openedx/config/lms.env.json /home/frohro/openedx-docker/deploy/templates/openedx/config/lms.env.json

Thanks, Rob

regisb commented 5 years ago

Let's solve issue #148 before we consider adding this feature by default. FYI, file /home/frohro/openedx-docker/deploy/env/openedx/lms.env.json is now useless and can be safely deleted.

frohro commented 5 years ago

I was going to ask you if it was safe to address this again, and it looks like it is, but I'm not certain this issue is really fixed. I am still seeing what the screenshot above shows. (No link appears.) In other words, it doesn't make the link I see on edunext.co in this screen shot. image Maybe I'm not waiting long enough, but it seems 15 minutes should be plenty of time for less than 20 students. Thanks! Rob

regisb commented 5 years ago

@frohro I think I may have found a way to solve this, but I'm currently working on more urgent issues. Is it ok if this waits a week or two?

frohro commented 5 years ago

Certainly!

Rob

Get Outlook for Androidhttps://aka.ms/ghei36


From: Régis Behmo notifications@github.com Sent: Thursday, February 7, 2019 12:36:24 AM To: regisb/tutor Cc: Rob Frohne; Mention Subject: Re: [regisb/tutor] Grade Download Needed (#143)

@frohrohttps://github.com/frohro I think I may have found a way to solve this, but I'm currently working on more urgent issues. Is it ok if this waits a week or two?

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/regisb/tutor/issues/143#issuecomment-461329963, or mute the threadhttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AA8tBQyxK5-wpIJ2S5nePm-zqB2EzGIHks5vK-WIgaJpZM4afdEI.

guilleironhack commented 5 years ago

I'm experiencing the same issue when trying to generate and download reports. In other order of things, I would also love to see analytics/insights in tutor!

regisb commented 5 years ago

@guilleironhack thanks for your feedback! Are you or your company willing to sponsor the development effort of adding insights?

guilleironhack commented 5 years ago

@regisb I would love to, but I currently don't have enough know-how or effort available to do this having in mind that, as you mentioned, analytics/insights is not precisely simple

regisb commented 5 years ago

I meant "sponsor" in the sense of "financial support" :smiley: :moneybag: Let me ask this another way: how much would you or your company be willing to pay to add support for Insights?

guilleironhack commented 5 years ago

Hahaha now I get it! We would love to be able to do it, but I'm afraid we're not there yet. I might be able to contribute with some human effort, but again, lacking a bit of knowledge here.

frohro commented 5 years ago

Hi Regis, Any chance you could look at this? I'm at the end of the term, and it would be really nice to export the data from edx, rather than typing it all into a spread sheet or something. Thanks, Rob

regisb commented 5 years ago

Hi @frohro, It was harder than I thought, but I think I managed to solve this issue. The feature will be present in release 3.2.1., which should become available in a couple minutes.

Can you please test the latest tutor version and check that it works for you?

frohro commented 5 years ago

Thanks Regis! I'm going to try upgrading again to tutor. Last attempt did not work, as detailed in the overhang.io discussion, and I also copied my problems to issue 155. Again, thanks for fixing this. It makes doing a blended learning thing much much easier.
Rob