politics-rewired / Spoke

Politics Rewired's fork of Spoke
GNU General Public License v3.0
36 stars 17 forks source link

Disambiguate 'sending' message state #1496

Open bchrobot opened 2 years ago

bchrobot commented 2 years ago

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.

The SENDING message status is currently overloaded. It could mean either a) issues in Switchboard or b) standard delays or queuing downstream. End users have no way to distinguish between the two and often open tickets concerned about a) when the issue is actually b).

Describe the solution you'd like

Revamp message status to better differentiate message state:

Describe alternatives you've considered

Leaving message states as-is and providing additional documentation/clarification instead.

Additional context

Further discussion in private Slack here.

bchrobot commented 2 years ago

Feedback requested from any/all @politics-rewired/organizing @hiemanshu @ajohn25 @ben-pr-p @ikehz

bengilvar commented 2 years ago

Organizing team loves breaking SENDING out into 4 distinct states!

hiemanshu commented 1 year ago

Changes required for each step of the way:

  1. Change in spoke, to update status to "QUEUED" once message has been sent to Switchboard.
  2. Once the message has been received by Switchboard, the status is updated to "<need status name here>"
  3. Switchboard sends the message to the telco, and once telco has recieved the message, switchboard calls /assemble-numbers-message-report and gives a report about message being sent, and spoke updates the status to "<need status name here>"
  4. No change here to change status to "DELIVERED"

@bchrobot thoughts?

bchrobot commented 1 year ago

@hiemanshu I don't fully follow. Are blank statuses in 2 and 3 placeholders, or actual blanks?

I think the first step is to map states and state transitions in Telnyx and Bandwidth (and maybe Twilio too) onto Switchboard and from there onto Spoke, then decide the best way to display that to end users, and then figure out the implementation details/changes.

hiemanshu commented 1 year ago

@hiemanshu I don't fully follow. Are blank statuses in 2 and 3 placeholders, or actual blanks?

Ah, they are place holders, I typed <NEEDS NAME> and I think Github formatting removed / changed that

I think the first step is to map states and state transitions in Telnyx and Bandwidth (and maybe Twilio too) onto Switchboard and from there onto Spoke, then decide the best way to display that to end users, and then figure out the implementation details/changes.

Sounds good! Looks like a good first issue for me to take up in Switchoard.