search

qpSHiNqp / airport-bssid

If you want to get associated to a specific bssid with Mac OS, use this one.
107 stars 34 forks source link

MacOS High Sierra doesn't respect the bssid given #7

Open MuhsinFatih opened 6 years ago

MuhsinFatih commented 6 years ago

issue #6 persists on High Sierra. This is extremely frustrating because my neighbour has an ac capable router (with the same ssid as mine, and I cannot change mine) that is faulty and my mac always wants to connect to it instead. I can't use internet at all

MuhsinFatih commented 6 years ago

I am curious, is there a chance anyone has a copy of an old airport executable, from an older version of MacOS? From when it had the option to associate with bssid?

Moorviper commented 6 years ago

check out an older revision and compile it ???

MuhsinFatih commented 6 years ago

check out where? it's not opensource you know. I searched for older builds but couldn't find one

Moorviper commented 6 years ago

clone out the repo / checkout the revision you want and build it with xcode ...

MuhsinFatih commented 6 years ago

I am not talking about this repo, I am talking about the airport utility that comes built-in in macos. If you read the question a teensy bit carefully before answering you would see that I am talking about the MacOS's built-in airport utility as I said: "from an older version of MacOS", not "from an earlier version of this repository" ...

Moorviper commented 6 years ago

what has this repo to do with the official airport app. then this is not a bug with airport-bssid.

It makes no sense to add a issue here.

MuhsinFatih commented 6 years ago

@Moorviper the intent of this issue was to remind that the tool does not work on macos sierra. My comment's intent was to see if I can find potential workaround in the meantime. Are you seriously incapable of interpreting very simple text?? I didn't mention the official airport app IN THE ISSUE DESCRIPTION I only mentioned in in comments. Comments are NOT the description of the issue, they are merely comments, hence the name.. Just read the goddamn issue and the comment again instead of proofreading and whining about it. It will take you 10 more seconds ffs.

Moorviper commented 6 years ago

ok but airport-bssid works for me on 10.11, 10.12 and 10.13 very well. Only with networks with band or client steering. But there it couldn't work.

alex-laties commented 6 years ago

airport-bssid does definitely work on 10.13 High Sierra. The trick though is that the results from option-click on the WiFi icon are cached and incorrect after running airport-bssid and connecting to a new BSSID.

To check that you have connected to the desired BSSID, you can do the following:

~> cd /System/Library/PrivateFrameworks/Apple80211.framework/Versions/A/Resources/
~> ./airport -I | grep BSSID
MuhsinFatih commented 6 years ago

Can you confirm from router panel as well? I spent days on this issue in my previous apartment and couldn't connect the router that I wanted, could airport cli be reporting wrong bssid?

pjvandehaar commented 5 years ago

@alex-laties That's not working for me on High Sierra 10.13.6. Here's what I'm trying:

$ git clone https://github.com/qpSHiNqp/airport-bssid.git
$ alias airport=/System/Library/PrivateFrameworks/Apple80211.framework/Versions/Current/Resources/airport

$ sudo airport -z

$ sudo ./airport-bssid/Build/airport-bssid en0 5e:<censored>
Notice: The interface en0 is in none phyMode.
<snipped, but desired network is highlighted>
Associated to network "xfinitywifi" (BSSID: 5e:<censored>)

$ sudo airport -I | grep BSSID
BSSID: e6:<censored>

Do you have any advice on what to do differently?

Related to what @Moorviper mentioned, perhaps xfinity routers are able to move me from 5GHz on the working router to 5GHz on the closer, broken one?

appleadams commented 5 years ago

I can confirm that I am having the same issue on Mojave. If their is anything that I can do I'm open to helping. Also, yah my issue is 100% with xfinitywifi

Moorviper commented 5 years ago

yes the newer xfinity routers do band steering by default so it could not work on your networks.

Maybe you can turn it off.

frakman1 commented 3 years ago

I am curious, is there a chance anyone has a copy of an old airport executable, from an older version of MacOS? From when it had the option to associate with bssid?

@MuhsinFatih What is the most recent version of OSX that would have this? Maybe I can get it off there or a VM

MuhsinFatih commented 3 years ago

@frakman1 I'm sorry, this was a long time ago and I don't remember the research I had done on this, and I'm occupied with other things at the moment