rdawg-pidinst / schema

RDA WG PIDINST Metadata Schema
Other
21 stars 4 forks source link

URL for 2 code list #9

Closed oggioniale closed 5 years ago

oggioniale commented 6 years ago

for the proprieties relatedIdentifierType and relationType I added the URL of vocabularies of terms

RKrahl commented 5 years ago

I'm not sure if the vocabularies defined by Geoscience Australia (GA) are suitable to be used as controlled list of values for the Instrument PIDs that we have in mind.

In particular, you suggest to use Association Type as defined by GA to be used for relationType. But I can't see how many terms defined there would make sense for an instrument. For instance:

to name only a few terms. What is this supposed to mean for an instrument?

On the other hand, I fail to find any suitable terms in the GA Association Types for some values currently listed in the schema:

This is a major issue, as I would consider these relations to be important for instrument PIDs.

Concerning the IGSN Codelist that you suggest to use for relatedIdentifierType, I don't quite understand what it is. It looks like a wild mixture of identifier types (ARK, DOI, Handle, IGSN, ISBN, …) and relation types (ContactPerson, Distributor, Funder, hasDocument, …). I can't see how the latter might be suitable values for relatedIdentifierType. More importantly, PIDINST is missing in this list.

markusstocker commented 5 years ago

I think @RKrahl makes valid points here. I also fail to see how the linked lists include necessary and sufficient terms for the schema here. Unless there are any objections from @oggioniale I propose to close this pull request without merging.

RKrahl commented 5 years ago

Close as discussed in today's meeting.