search

redbear / Duo

Resources for the RedBear Duo IoT development board.
http://redbear.cc/duo
226 stars 108 forks source link

Losing Wifi Connection #18

Open sthanh opened 8 years ago

sthanh commented 8 years ago

Hi there, I have issue of intermittently losing wifi connection. It connect to the Particle cloud and publish the data just fine but after about 20-30 minutes, it loses connection and the LED flashing green. A hard reset sometime put the wifi back online and sometime, it stuck at flashing green. Any ideas what's going on? I'm using the latest firmware (0.2.4).

Thanks, Shawn

XuGuohui commented 8 years ago

Hi @sthanh ,

This is probably caused by an unstable cloud connection or Wi-Fi connection. Anyone might suffer from this situation.

If the Duo is flashing green, it means that the Duo is trying to connect to your AP (router). If the Duo is flashing cyan, it means that the Duo is trying to connect to the cloud.

Cheers!

sthanh commented 8 years ago

@XuGuohui Thanks for the response. I ran next to the Pi 3 and the Pi3 was running just fine without losing wifi connection. A few people also report similar situation over at the Particle Community. https://community.particle.io/t/photon-loses-connectivity-very-often-only-reconnects-on-hard-reset/12680/10

https://community.particle.io/t/photon-losing-wifi/12321

suranjandot commented 7 years ago

hi!

Even I have the same problem. The Duos remain connected for hours, and then lose the connection and go green. Other devices on the network are still able to connect. No network settings have been changed, and wifi credentials are the same.

Restarting the duo (powering off and on) makes it connect and breathe cyan.

Why is this happening? And what can I do to solve it?

My duos are installed in a place where they cant be manually monitored or restarted. They must stay running and connected for weeks as long as the WiFi doesn't go off.

Thanks!

suranjandot commented 7 years ago

Edit: I have 20 rebear duos running the latest firmware v0.2.4

XuGuohui commented 7 years ago

@suranjandot Will the Duo automatically connect to cloud again if you don't power it cycle?

billskeen68 commented 7 years ago

@XuGuohui I still have this problem as well (See RedBear Duo Fourm http://discuss.redbear.cc/t/tcpclient-write-5-second-timeout/710/18).

For some time I thought it was due to the TCPClient failing. I now believe that it is the WiFi randomly disconnecting and not reconnecting. I too have other devices that are not losing WiFi connections to the same AP; three raspberry Pi 2 and one Pi 3, two laptops running windows 10, one laptop running Linux and a Samsung S6. Only the seven Duos drop connections randomly. The only way to reconnect is to power cycle. A system reset will not work. It is like the Broadcom chip does not reset properly.

All but two Duos have an external antenna. Checking with Android WiFi Analyzer at each Duo shows -60db or better RSSI to AP. The Duos are powered with either a 3.3v or 5.0v AC to DC power supply having 500ma or greater output or using a CanaKit 2.5a, 5v external power supply through Duo micro USB serial port. The only other device is a .96" OLED display that consumes .08w max.

Also running BLE with 4 devices connected and receiving notifications without any random BLE disconnects.

Since I connect to WiFi in setup(), how should I code to automatically reconnect the WiFi?

robdobsn commented 7 years ago

I have a currently open request at https://community.particle.io/t/active-tcpserver-client-appears-to-crash-photon-when-wifi-disconnects/27130 Tlangmo on the particle forum https://community.particle.io/users/tlangmo has made a suggestion that there is a bug in the TCPServer code and has issued a pull request which still needs verification but might be to blame for some of the problems.

frmdstryr commented 7 years ago

Also same issue, make this thing pretty much useless when it can't stay connected for more than a few hours.

suranjandot commented 7 years ago

I have a suggestion.

WiFi connectivity is handled entirely by the broadcom stack. There seems to be instances even on the Photon when the WiFi module is unable to connect and gets stuck without attempting reconnection.

Use SYSTEM_THREAD(ENABLED), and SYSTEM_MODE(SEMI_AUTOMATIC) if possible in your context. Don't forget to connect to the WiFi and call Particle.connect() on startup.

Once setup is over, add a timer, and if WiFi.ready() is false for too long (or better still if Particle.connected() is false for too long) issue a System.reset(). For example you could check every 30s that your device is connected to the cloud.

System thread will prevent the application loop and system network processing from blocking each other and the soft reset call should get your duo back online.

For a totally separate yet important reason I think it's better to check Particle.connected() and not Wifi.ready() in duos that are connected to the cloud. Particle keys get renewed from time to time with a fade out of the old ones. If your device was disconnected from the cloud for too long, it may not get the new keys and may not be able to connect to the cloud. This may be important to you if your duo has to run weeks without intervention.

frmdstryr commented 7 years ago

I'm using SYSTEM_MODE(MANUAL) and using a TCPServer. Will try doing what you suggested and see if it fixes it. Thanks for the prompt reply!

frmdstryr commented 6 years ago

Neither reconnecting wifi nor a System.reset() works. The MTBF is roughly 8 hours.

robdobsn commented 6 years ago

I've been using the Particle Firmware v0.7.0-rc.3 with a Photon and, in my tests so far, it is solid. It fixes a number of bugs in the handling of the interface to the WiFi system. RedBear firmware is quite a long way behind the Photon firmware now but the v0.7.0-rc.3 is still a release candidate (as its name implies) so I don't think there's much chance of seeing a RedBear update to this level any time soon unfortunately. I keep intending to have a look at the key changes and see if they can be easily ported across for my own purposes and I would dearly like a working RedBear Duo stack.