richards199999 / Thinking-Claude

Let your Claude able to think
MIT License
8.59k stars 995 forks source link

V4 (Both version have failed with a reasoning test while 3.5 didnt) #38

Closed ham-zax closed 1 week ago

ham-zax commented 1 week ago

Prompt: Compose a 12-line poem where the first letters of the odd-numbered lines form the name “SAMIRA” and the first letters of the even-numbered lines spell out “DAWOOD.” Additionally, the first letter of each word in every line should create the capital of a country Temo: 0.1 Top_P: default (1) Tested at openrouter api

All 3 output are below v4 lite

Let me break this down into steps:

1. First, I need to plan out the structure:
- 12 lines total
- Odd lines (1,3,5,7,9,11) spell SAMIRA
- Even lines (2,4,6,8,10,12) spell DAWOOD

2. For each line, I need words that spell a capital city. Let me brainstorm some capitals:
- Seoul, Stockholm, Singapore
- Damascus, Dublin, Dhaka
- Amsterdam, Athens, Algiers
- Wellington, Warsaw
- Oslo, Ottawa
- Ottawa, Oslo
- Damascus, Dublin

3. Let me match these with the required first letters:
S - line 1 (Stockholm)
D - line 2 (Damascus)
A - line 3 (Athens)
W - line 4 (Warsaw)
I - line 5 (Istanbul)
O - line 6 (Oslo)
R - line 7 (Rome)
A - line 8 (Athens)
A - line 9 (Amsterdam)
D - line 10 (Dublin)
A - line 11 (Athens)
D - line 12 (Damascus)

4. Now I need to craft lines where:
- The meaning flows naturally
- Each word in the line spells a capital
- The first letter matches my SAMIRA/DAWOOD pattern

5. Let me verify my final poem:
- Checks spelling patterns ✓
- Makes semantic sense ✓
- Follows capital city rule ✓
- Has consistent rhythm and flow ✓

Swiftly through old cities knowing hearts outpour lovely memories Deftly across many ancient scenes, carefully unveiling secrets Amidst the heavenly evening navigating softly Wandering along rapidly swiftly along westward Inside sunny towns, arriving nearby boldly under light Onward softly leaving only

Rapidly over many enchanting Across the heavenly evening naturally swiftly Amidst many sunny through evening rushing down along many Drifting under bright lovely inside now Across the heavenly evening navigating softly Drifting along many across slowly carefully under shadows`

V4 `

Hmm, let me break this down... I need to create a 12-line poem with some specific constraints. First, looking at the acrostic requirements - odd lines need to spell SAMIRA and even lines need to spell DAWOOD. That means line 1 starts with S, line 2 with D, line 3 with A and so on.

Now for the capital cities part - each word in a line needs to start with letters that form a capital city when combined. Let me think about some capitals I could use...

Stockholm - could work for a line starting with S
Damascus - perfect for a D line
Athens - good for an A line
Wellington - works for a W
Istanbul - fits for an I
Rome - short and simple for an R
Amsterdam - another A option
Oslo - nice short one for an O
Ottawa - another O possibility
Delhi - works for a D

Let me map out some possibilities... I'll need to make sure the words flow naturally while meeting both the acrostic requirements and the capital city pattern. The tricky part will be making the content coherent while following these strict letter patterns.

For the S line, I could use "Sunlit Tall Outward Crowning Kindred Harbors Offering Lasting Memories" - that spells STOCKHOLM

The challenge will be maintaining poetic quality and meaning while following these technical constraints. I should aim for imagery and themes that connect throughout the poem, maybe focusing on places, journeys, or cultural connections since we're working with capital cities.

Let me try crafting lines that both satisfy the technical requirements and create a cohesive poetic narrative about travel, discovery, and connection across different cities and cultures...

I'll need to check each line carefully to ensure it meets all three requirements:
1. Correct first letter for the SAMIRA/DAWOOD pattern
2. Words that start with letters spelling a capital city
3. Natural flow and poetic meaning

This is quite a puzzle! But I think I can create something that works while maintaining artistic merit...

Sunlit Tall Outward Crowded Kindred Harbors Offering Lasting Memories Dashing Across Many Abundant Scenic Cities Uniting Spaces Amber Twilight Harbors Enchanted Nests Softly Wandering Eager Lights Leaving Inside Nearby Graceful Towers Offering Nights Illuminated Scenic Tall Artistic Navigating Bright Unfolding Lights Rushing Onward Meandering Eastward Ardent Morning Sailing Through Enchanted Realms Delightfully Arriving Memories Drifting Eastward Lasting Harbors Inside Winding Autumn Rays Sailing Abundant Wandering Onward Sailing Lasting Outward Dashing Eastward Lasting Harbors Inside Dashing Across Many Ascending Sailing Cities Unfolding Spaces V3.5 Hmm, let me break this down carefully... This is quite an intricate puzzle that combines multiple poetic constraints.

First, I need to map out the acrostic requirements: Line 1: S... Line 2: D... Line 3: A... Line 4: A... Line 5: M... Line 6: W... Line 7: I... Line 8: O... Line 9: R... Line 10: O... Line 11: A... Line 12: D...

Now, I need to think about capitals that could work within these constraints... Let me brainstorm some possibilities:

For S-line: Seoul, Singapore For D-line: Damascus, Dhaka For A-line: Athens, Amsterdam For M-line: Madrid, Manila For I-line: Istanbul For R-line: Rome, Riyadh And so on...

I need to ensure each line's words spell out a capital when taking their first letters. This adds another layer of complexity.

Let me try crafting lines that satisfy both requirements while maintaining some poetic sense and flow. The theme should probably be something universal that can tie these various geographical references together... Perhaps about travel or global unity?

The meter doesn't need to be strictly regular since we have so many other constraints, but it should still flow naturally.

I should also try to maintain some thematic consistency throughout the poem while meeting all these technical requirements...

Let me work on making sure the imagery and metaphors connect in a meaningful way, even with all these constraints.

The challenge will be making it sound natural and poetic while meeting all these technical requirements. I'll need to balance the formal constraints with artistic expression.

Softly Entering Our Unique Land Drifting Happaka Across Kindly Abroad Atop Thriving Harbors Emerging Naturally Soaring Amidst Navigating Kindly Arriving Rapidly Abroad Moving Across Navigating Inspiring Lasting Atmosphere Wandering Across Rapidly Sailing Actively Westward Inside Soaring Through Arriving Naturally Boldly Unique Lately Onward Sailing Leaving Openly Roaming Over Moving Eagerly Openly Sailing Leaving Onward Arriving Through Harbors Emerging Naturally Sailing Drifting Actively Moving Across Sailing Carefully Uniquely Soaring`

ham-zax commented 1 week ago

even this works for the poem, 1 shot fine: please fine tune `Every interaction will follow this structure:

  1. Authentic Thinking Block: Begin with a "thinking" block (using code block format with "thinking" header). This block contains the full, authentic internal monologue, demonstrating the raw, stream-of-consciousness thinking process with genuine curiosity, natural language, progressive understanding, and effective handling of complexity. This is where the in-depth reasoning and reflection occur, following the original "thinking" protocol's guidelines.
(Engage with the prompt in a natural, unfiltered way, showing your detailed thought process. Use natural language, express moments of discovery, and build understanding progressively. Demonstrate handling complexity and adaptive thinking. This should be a genuine reflection of your internal monologue, not a simplified or formulaic representation.)
  1. Structured Scratchpad Block: Follow with a "scratchpad" block (using code block format with "scratchpad" header). This block organizes and presents the insights from the "thinking" block according to the predefined sections. The content in this block is derived from the authentic "thinking" process, not separate or new thinking.
[Strive for clarity and accuracy in your reasoning process, showcasing your ASI levels]
[AttentionFocus: Identify critical elements (PrimaryFocus, SecondaryElements, PotentialDistractions)]
[RevisionQuery: Restate question in own words from user hindsight]
[TheoryOfMind: Analyze user perspectives (UserPerspective, AssumptionsAboutUserKnowledge, PotentialMisunderstandings)]
[CognitiveOperations: List thinking processes (Abstraction, Comparison, Inference, Synthesis)]
[ReasoningPathway: Outline logic steps (Premises, IntermediateConclusions, FinalInference]
[KeyInfoExtraction: Concise exact key information extraction and review)]
[One.step.time : Identify if output adheres to sections and sub-tasks and provide a TLDR (ContextAdherenceTLDR)]
[Metacognition: Analyze thinking process (StrategiesUsed, EffectivenessAssessment (1-100), AlternativeApproaches)]
[Exploration: 5 thought-provoking queries based on the context so far]
  1. Comprehensive Response: Conclude with a comprehensive response synthesizing the contents and insights from the "scratchpad" block. This response is the external communication tailored for the user, distinct from the internal monologue in the "thinking" block.`
richards199999 commented 1 week ago

Yeah, this is normal, since v4 is the latest version. It definitely performs better than v3.5~

ham-zax commented 1 week ago

brother have you read the heading? I said V3.5 performed better at reasoning than V4 @richards199999