Plugin De-Duplicating EC2 Nodes with same name?

[treeves]

I have a number of auto-scaling groups that create nodes that, whilst having different EC2 tags, all have the same instance "name". It seems that the plugin is de-duplicating instances that have the same name and is not displaying them as nodes in Rundeck.

I.e. when I log in to the EC2 console, I have 330 running instances that come up. In Rundeck, only 218 appear when I pull with the same key via the EC2 plugin.

Each ASG that I have for each environment (dev, qa, stage, uat, etc) has multiple instances, all with the same instance name (although different tags, security groups, etc). Like:

Name Tag

fff-dev1-cq5-stack AuthorAutoscaleGroup fff-dev1-cq5-stack PublishAutoscaleGroup fff-dev1-cq5-stack DispatchAutoscaleGroup

But in Rundeck, only one of the above appears.

Is there something I can do to convince it that different instances are different, even if they have the same name?

[gschueler]

Rundeck uses the node "name" as the unique identifier. If you have instances with the same "name", you will need to switch to a unique value for the nodename.

I think you would need to use the instanceId as the nodename selector.

The ec2 plugin doesn't really support any composition of values to produce a field value, i think that would be a useful feature however.

[patelgaurang83]

I had the same issue. I solved it by changing the below value in mapping.properties file.

From: nodename.selector=tags/Name,instanceId To: nodename.selector=instanceId

[scalp42]

Same issue here, with ASGs of more than 10 nodes, only end up seeing 1.

Unfortunately, relying on instanceID makes it non user friendly :sake:

[gschueler]

@scalp42 would allowing something like tags/Name+instanceId (combine the two) be sufficient?

[scalp42]

yes @gschueler would totally work :+1:

I think the only issue is how do you handle something like "$name-$instanceid", meaning with a dash etc and would compounding multiple ones with multiples + allowed, just for thoughts.

[scalp42]

Also, at this point anything would be great but worth mentioning that some folks might have the + in the actual name:

Allowed characters for all regions are letters, spaces, and numbers representable in UTF-8, plus the following special characters: + - = . _ : / @

So tricky at best :sake:

[gschueler]

It definitely makes the mapping syntax more complicated.

+ allowed in instance names is probably fine, it wouldn't affect the mapping syntax, as the value would be expanded in place.

I was imagining using + to append multiple values. and allowing a quoted value to be a literal string, like:

nodename.selector=tags/Name+'-'+instanceId

would become "$name-$id" effectively

[scalp42]

Oh that makes sense, yeah would totally work!

PS: if I had Java chops, I'd def help :speak_no_evil:

[gschueler]

@scalp42 that was recently filed as an issue as well, see https://github.com/rundeck-plugins/rundeck-ec2-nodes-plugin/issues/41

the workaround is to configure two instances of the ec2 source

[gschueler]

@scalp42 sorry i misunderstood. you mean in the rundeck search? you can search tags: mesos-slave+gz-prod

[scalp42]

@gschueler got it :)

[wilddog64]

does this get resolved in rundeck 2.6.4? I am more interesting to know how to setup this from the mappingParam at UI level. Now I have the syntax like this,

description.default=tags/Name;nodename.selector=privateDnsName;hostname.selector=privateIpAddress;

Although it mapped the node, but it can't de-deplicate the node instances. I'd like to see one to many mapping for my autoscaling group: X --> x1, x2, x3, ... xN.

How can I accomplish that by mappingParams