search

rzellem / EXOTIC

EXOplanet Transit Interpretation Code
Other
86 stars 45 forks source link

Resolve TypeError for noisy or drifting background imaging #1340

Closed ivenzor closed 2 weeks ago

ivenzor commented 2 weeks ago 
  File "/usr/local/bin/exotic", line 8, in <module>
    sys.exit(main())
  File "/usr/local/lib/python3.10/dist-packages/exotic/exotic.py", line 2222, in main
    aper_data[f"{ckey}_bg"][i][a][an] = aperPhot(imageData, j + 1, psf_data[ckey][i, 0],
  File "/usr/local/lib/python3.10/dist-packages/exotic/exotic.py", line 1256, in aperPhot
    aperture_sum = (mask.data * (data_cutout - bgflux)).sum()
TypeError: unsupported operand type(s) for -: 'NoneType' and 'float'
ivenzor commented 2 weeks ago

The issue appears to happen when comparison stars drift near the border, but also in other weird cases such as the second one (I added this warning to find more about the issues):

Finding transformation 21 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529040312.FITS.gz
Warning: Aperture outside image bounds for star index 6 at position (181.7890170460345, -8.942431356537716)
Finding transformation 44 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529051212.FITS.gz
Warning: Aperture outside image bounds for star index 4 at position (-7683.0, 2081.5)

@tamimfatahi @pearsonkyle To avoid these errors, we could check if by any reason data_cutout return None, something like the following:

# Method calculates the flux of the star (uses the skybg_phot method to do background sub)
def aperPhot(data, starIndex, xc, yc, r=5, dr=5):
    # Check for invalid coordinates
    if np.isnan(xc) or np.isnan(yc):
        return 0, 0

    # Calculate background if dr > 0
    if dr > 0:
        bgflux, sigmabg, Nbg = skybg_phot(data, starIndex, xc, yc, r + 2, dr)
    else:
        bgflux, sigmabg, Nbg = 0, 0, 0

    # Create aperture and mask
    aperture = CircularAperture(positions=[(xc, yc)], r=r)
    mask = aperture.to_mask(method='exact')[0]
    data_cutout = mask.cutout(data)

    # Check if aperture is valid
    if data_cutout is None:
        # Aperture is partially or fully outside the image
        return 0, bgflux    # Return zero flux but valid background

    # Calculate and return aperture sum
    aperture_sum = (mask.data * (data_cutout - bgflux)).sum()
    return aperture_sum, bgflux

Let me know if this make sense to you, I can submit a PR to dev.

tamimfatahi commented 2 weeks ago

This looks great. Are the images poor where the error occurs? Is EXOTIC correctly identifying these errors (specifically the second case it sounds like)?

ivenzor commented 2 weeks ago

@tamimfatahi the images were not that bad, a little bit of drifting and some clouds but I have definitely worked with more challenging datasets in the past.

EXOTIC is currently not identifying these errors, the execution is stopped with the following error: TypeError: unsupported operand type(s) for -: 'NoneType' and 'float' The warning was issued after I explicitly changed the function to check if data_cutout is None

tamimfatahi commented 2 weeks ago

Hmm interesting. Could you possibly send the dataset?

And that sounds great. Please open the PR and I will go ahead and verify it.

ivenzor commented 2 weeks ago

Full log with original comparison stars:

(exotic_env) C:\Users\ivenz\exotic_temp\EXOTIC\exotic>python exotic.py -red "C:/Users/ivenz/Downloads/9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001/
inits.json"
Importing Python Packages - please wait.
    Downloading __databases__.pickle_new...
    Done!- ...
Checking exotethys database...
Checking ephemerides database...
Checking photometry database...
Checking catalogues database...
Thinking ... DONE!

*************************************************************
Welcome to the EXOplanet Transit Interpretation Code (EXOTIC)
Version 4.2.2
*************************************************************

**************************
Complete Reduction Routine
**************************

Looking up WASP-107 b on the NASA Exoplanet Archive. Please wait....
Successfully found WASP-107 b in the NASA Exoplanet Archive!
Generated random number seed 1262702495

**************************
Starting Reduction Process
**************************

Getting the plate solution for your imaging file to translate pixel coordinates on the sky.
Please wait....
WCS file creation successful.
Thinking ... DONE!

Here is the path to your plate solution: C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\outputs\temp\wcs.fits

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #1:
        Pixel X: 259 Pixel Y: 83

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #2:
        Pixel X: 169 Pixel Y: 260

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #3:
        Pixel X: 126 Pixel Y: 316

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #4:
        Pixel X: 361 Pixel Y: 177

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #5:
        Pixel X: 591 Pixel Y: 110

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #6:
        Pixel X: 188 Pixel Y: 20

No comparison stars were gathered from AAVSO.

Dark subtracting images.
Finding transformation 1 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529032337.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 2 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529032515.FITS.gz
 Comparison star #6 star beyond edge of file C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529032515.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 3 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529032653.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 4 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529032831.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 5 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033009.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 6 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033147.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 7 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033327.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 8 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033505.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 9 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033643.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 10 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033821.FITS.gz
 Sky background error for Comparison star #5 for file C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033821.FITS.gz - are you sure there is a star at [649.4, 49.6]?
Finding transformation 11 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033959.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 12 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529034137.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 13 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529034315.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 14 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529034453.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 15 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529034631.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 16 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529034812.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 17 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529035112.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 18 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529035412.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 19 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529035712.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 20 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529040012.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 21 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529040312.FITS.gz
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "C:\Users\ivenz\exotic_temp\EXOTIC\exotic\exotic.py", line 2743, in <module>
    main()
  File "C:\Users\ivenz\exotic_temp\EXOTIC\exotic\exotic.py", line 2222, in main
    aper_data[f"{ckey}_bg"][i][a][an] = aperPhot(imageData, j + 1, psf_data[ckey][i, 0],
                                        ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
  File "C:\Users\ivenz\exotic_temp\EXOTIC\exotic\exotic.py", line 1256, in aperPhot
    aperture_sum = (mask.data * (data_cutout - bgflux)).sum()
                                 ~~~~~~~~~~~~^~~~~~~~
TypeError: unsupported operand type(s) for -: 'NoneType' and 'float'
ivenzor commented 2 weeks ago

Partial log with function changes:

(exotic_env) C:\Users\ivenz\issue_1340\EXOTIC\exotic>python exotic.py -red "C:/Users/ivenz/Downloads/9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001/inits.json"
Importing Python Packages - please wait.
    Downloading __databases__.pickle_new...
    Done!| ...
Checking exotethys database...
Checking ephemerides database...
Checking photometry database...
Checking catalogues database...
Thinking ... DONE!

*************************************************************
Welcome to the EXOplanet Transit Interpretation Code (EXOTIC)
Version 4.2.2
*************************************************************

**************************
Complete Reduction Routine
**************************

Looking up WASP-107 b on the NASA Exoplanet Archive. Please wait....
Successfully found WASP-107 b in the NASA Exoplanet Archive!
Generated random number seed 1262702495

**************************
Starting Reduction Process
**************************

Getting the plate solution for your imaging file to translate pixel coordinates on the sky.
Please wait....
WCS file creation successful.
Thinking ... DONE!

Here is the path to your plate solution: C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\outputs\temp\wcs.fits

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #1:
        Pixel X: 259 Pixel Y: 83

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #2:
        Pixel X: 169 Pixel Y: 260

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #3:
        Pixel X: 126 Pixel Y: 316

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #4:
        Pixel X: 361 Pixel Y: 177

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #5:
        Pixel X: 591 Pixel Y: 110

Checking for variability in Comparison Star #6:
        Pixel X: 188 Pixel Y: 20

No comparison stars were gathered from AAVSO.

Dark subtracting images.
Finding transformation 1 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529032337.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 2 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529032515.FITS.gz
 Comparison star #6 star beyond edge of file C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529032515.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 3 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529032653.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 4 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529032831.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 5 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033009.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 6 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033147.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 7 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033327.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 8 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033505.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 9 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033643.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 10 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033821.FITS.gz
 Sky background error for Comparison star #5 for file C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033821.FITS.gz - are you sure there is a star at [649.4, 49.6]?
Finding transformation 11 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529033959.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 12 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529034137.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 13 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529034315.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 14 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529034453.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 15 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529034631.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 16 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529034812.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 17 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529035112.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 18 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529035412.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 19 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529035712.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 20 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529040012.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 21 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529040312.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 22 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529040612.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 23 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529040912.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 24 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529041212.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 25 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529041512.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 26 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529041812.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 27 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529042112.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 28 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529042412.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 29 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529042713.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 30 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529043012.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 31 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529043312.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 32 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529043612.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 33 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529043912.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 34 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529044212.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 35 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529044512.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 36 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529044812.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 37 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529045112.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 38 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529045412.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 39 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529045712.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 40 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529050012.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 41 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529050312.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 42 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529050612.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 43 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529050912.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 44 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529051212.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 45 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529051512.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 46 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529051812.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 47 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529052112.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 48 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529052412.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 49 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529052712.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 50 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529053012.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 51 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529053312.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 52 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529053612.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 53 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529053912.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 54 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529054212.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 55 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529054512.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 56 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529054812.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 57 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529055112.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 58 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529055412.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 59 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529055712.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 60 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529060012.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 61 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529060312.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 62 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529060612.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 63 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529060912.FITS.gz
Finding transformation 64 of 64 : C:\Users\ivenz\Downloads\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e-20241103T223534Z-001\9aea8f2e5c67db1b07861583a6ae482e\MOBS_Cecilia_WASP-107_2021-05-28T19_43_48.971-0700_f142031ed571c5c93969786c1d0cc830_WASP-107210529061212.FITS.gz

Computing best comparison star, aperture, and sky annulus. Please wait.
ivenzor commented 2 weeks ago

@tamimfatahi I have sent you the dataset in Slack DM

jpl-jengelke commented 2 weeks ago

This is also affecting reductions at the Table Mountain Facility (TMF). I have a screenshot here with the exact same error. tmf_exotic_error

Heath also has a way to reproduce the error consistently. It dumps on the same image every time.

jpl-jengelke commented 2 weeks ago

Since this is a recurrent issue that blocks reductions for certain users with certain noisy datasets, I've merged PR #1341 and will do a release as a version 4.2.3 Hotfix.

tamimfatahi commented 2 weeks ago

Seems like this got merged (PR #1341), closing for now. Thanks @ivenzor!

I also think it will be interesting to look more into why this is occurring.