search

sdmx-twg / vtl

This repository is used for maintaining the SDMX-VTL specification
11 stars 7 forks source link

Harmonise the use of "," and ";" #260

Closed stratosn closed 1 year ago

stratosn commented 7 years ago
reporter issue reference document (UM/RM/EBNF) page line
ECB2-8 RM 32,46,52 838, 1512, 1736

Issue Description

It would make sense to harmonize the usage of “,” and “;” (i.e. symbols to split objects / lines). For example in case of a datapoint ruleset (see line 838) the symbol “;” is used to separate the individual rules. In case of a join expression (see line 1736) each clause of the join body is separated by the symbol “,” which is also the separator for methods applied in a get() function (see line 1512).

Proposed Solution

Harmonise the use of , and ;

fewagener commented 7 years ago

It seems the comma "," is more widely used in VTL as a separator. So, I would change the semicolon ";" with a comma in datapoint ruleset

vignola commented 7 years ago

can we consider this issue similar to #338 ?