evaluation paper todo

[sdtaylor]

Writing

• [x] confirm the 3 methodologies (climatology, climatology + current year temp, current year temp + temp forecasts) are consistently named and lettered (a,b,c) throughout methods,results,discussion,supplement.
• [x] abstract
• [x] npn data cite
• [x] all software citations
• [x] acknowledgements (not in main paper, they go in a special submission box)
• [x] moore funding statement in acknowledgements for bioarxiv version
• [x] ethan affiliations
• [ ] do latex /refs so peerj will have an easier time. (though not technically needed till resubmission)

Logistics

• [x] clean up eval code on serenity
• [x] upload zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3990010
• [x] collect / confirm all references
• [x] cover page
• [x] save all figures to files

[sdtaylor]

npn data citaiton

For publications using USA-NPN contemporary data collected through Nature’s Notebook since 2008: USA National Phenology Network. Year of dataset access. Plant and Animal Phenology Data. Data type: [Status and Intensity, Individual Phenometrics, Site Phenometrics or Magnitude Phenometrics]. [Date range of data used] for Region: [Coordinates]. USA-NPN, Tucson, Arizona, USA. Data set accessed [Date] at http://doi.org/10.5066/F78S4N1V

data for model building, from 2008-2017

@Misc{npndata2017,
  Author = {{USA National Phenology Network}},
  Howpublished = {USA-NPN, Tucson, Arizona, USA. Data set accessed 07/08/2018 at \url{http://doi.org/10.5066/F78S4N1V}},
  Title = {Plant and Animal Phenology Data. Data type: Individual Phenometrics. 01/01/2008-12/31/2017 for Region: 49.9375°, -66.4791667° (UR); 24.0625°, -125.0208333° (LL).},
  Year = {2018},
}

data for simple eval, from 2019

@Misc{npndata2019,
  Author = {{USA National Phenology Network}},
  Howpublished = {USA-NPN, Tucson, Arizona, USA. Data set accessed 05/09/2019 at \url{http://doi.org/10.5066/F78S4N1V}},
  Title = {Plant and Animal Phenology Data. Data type: Individual Phenometrics. 01/01/2019-05/08/2019 for Region: 49.9375°, -66.4791667° (UR); 24.0625°, -125.0208333° (LL).},
  Year = {2019},
}

[sdtaylor]

acknowledgements.

moore foundation, npn. jornada?

This research was supported by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation’s Data-Driven Discovery Initiative through Grant GBMF4563 to E.P. White. We thank the USA National Phenology Network and the many participants who contribute to its Nature’s Notebook program.

[sdtaylor]

Cover page

should be page 1 of manuscript

Author Cover Page structure:

Article title
Authors
    First given names (or first initials in combination with full middle names).
    Middle name initial(s).
    Family name (surname).
Affiliations (indicate multiple affiliations, or current addresses where appropriate).
    Department, university, or organizational affiliation.
    Location: city, state/province (if applicable).
    Country.
Corresponding Author
    First and Last name.
    Email address.

[sdtaylor]

cover letter

Near-term ecological forecasts are becoming more mainstream. As researchers build out these tools they'll have to decide whether to integrate climate variables from near-term weather forecasts. Data on the future climate in the next 12 months may seem ideal, but only a handful of studies have actually done this so far. Here we perform