sharingspace / PEARL

People’s Ethical Appropriation Reciprocity License
Other
3 stars 0 forks source link

Is it open source? #19

Open Aspie96 opened 4 years ago

Aspie96 commented 4 years ago

is an open source license

I am not sure about that.

See, the problem is:

If you modify, distribute, sell, or otherwise use Covered Items for a profit, or sell knowledge/services for Covered Items, you agree to disclose the following to the Maker(s):

This is very tricky. It defenitely wouldn't be considered free software, but when it comes to open source is tricky. The point is, it's only open source if having to disclose such information does not discriminate against any field of endeavor.

I very much suggest you not to call it "open source" until this has been clarified trough OSI approval.

Additionally:

With open source licenses, there are no financial benefits for the Makers and maintainers.

That is not necessarely the case.

On the contrary, open source projects are often used to make profit by businesses who don’t reciprocate value at all.

True.

PEARL fixes this issue

It should be explained how this was ever an issue to begin with.