search

tastejs / todomvc

Helping you select an MV* framework - Todo apps for React.js, Ember.js, Angular, and many more
http://todomvc.com
Other
28.65k stars 13.77k forks source link

React+Flux and the rules against transpilers #998

Open fisherwebdev opened 10 years ago

fisherwebdev commented 10 years ago

I see that there is some movement toward including projects that rely on a transpile step, with TasteLang in issue #945. I'd very much like to submit a Flux TodoMVC example that includes the use of React's JSX syntax, as this has been the canonical way of writing Flux apps and the existing Flux community is moving in that direction. Should I wait to submit Flux until these issues are resolved, or should I submit a PR now (or the next day or two) and let Flux become one of the first compile-to-JS projects?

I think submitting Flux with a Vanilla JS implementation would actually confuse newcomers to the Flux community more than I'd like.

To see the current state of our TodoMVC Flux implementation, check out the Flux repo: https://github.com/facebook/flux/tree/master/examples/flux-todomvc

sindresorhus commented 10 years ago

or should I submit a PR now (or the next day or two) and let Flux become one of the first compile-to-JS projects?

I would be ok with that.

// @tastejs/owners

passy commented 10 years ago

I'd be very happy to see a proper Flux example. We are going to change the transpiler rule very shortly anyway. On Sep 16, 2014 6:17 PM, "Sindre Sorhus" notifications@github.com wrote:

or should I submit a PR now (or the next day or two) and let Flux become one of the first compile-to-JS projects?

I would be ok with that.

// @tastejs/owners https://github.com/orgs/tastejs/teams/owners

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/tastejs/todomvc/issues/998#issuecomment-55778038.

addyosmani commented 10 years ago

As I said on Twitter, I'm more than happy for a Flux implementation to land. Also happy for us to relax the rules around transpilers (@passy is going to update them soon).