Open Dimoka113 opened 2 months ago
LWChris
commented
2 months ago I would argue the bug is that the message re-appears after closing. Deleting a message should delete it. In my opinion, quoting a message shouldn't fixate it, as that would compromise the user's ability to delete a message at their own terms.
Dimoka113
commented
2 months ago Well, I’m not entirely sure that the telegram mechanics can and/or should be discussed here (specifically its api, because the “quote_text” value is in the messageReplyHeader I just pointed out the differences between Telegram Desktop and other clients (example Telegram on Android)
Quote before deleting message:
Quote after deleting a message:
LWChris
commented
2 months ago Your screenshots are confusing to me. The deleted message appears to have been "Original message" but the quote only says "message" in both screenshots as if it was referencing a different message.
In Android, if I write 3 messages, 2 and 3 in reply to the previous one, I get this behavior:
Original:
1
1
2
2
3
If deleting message 1:
2
2
3
If deleting message 2:
1
3
If deleting message 3:
1
1
2
And that is what I described - when you delete a quoted message, the quoted message and the quote from the reply disappear. So I don't think your "Expected behaviour: The text of the quote should remain" is correct.
Steps to reproduce
Expected behaviour
The text of the quote should remain
Actual behaviour
Instead of a quote, only “deleted message” remains.
In addition, I can say that if you completely close the telegram using “ctrl + q”, then after opening the chat with this message, the quote will appear
Operating system
Windows 10
Version of Telegram Desktop
5.5.3
Installation source
Static binary from official website
Crash ID
No response
Logs
No response