tonkeeper / wallet

GNU General Public License v3.0
331 stars 85 forks source link

Unsuccessful transaction in HMSTR transfer #973

Open Saraylu opened 5 days ago

Saraylu commented 5 days ago

In this transaction, I was charged a higher fee(0.065 TON) than what the Tonkeeper wallet indicated(0.015 TON), and the transaction was not completed. I repeated the transaction three more times and it failed each time. Every transaction attempt resulted in a failure code of 48, witch apparently indicates an insufficient transaction fee. This is puzzling as I had a balance significantly higher than the required fee in my Tonkeeper wallet.

I expected the transaction to carry out or report the problem properly. But a few times it just charged me a fee without explaining why!

Phone OS: Android 13 TKQ1.221013.002 Wallet: Tonkeeper 5.0.15 (877) - v4R2

These are all my failed transactions: https://tonviewer.com/transaction/c2b6848c9f7344f3c8c7888dc5195a763be6fc51319aa43b928a3ff540655365 https://tonviewer.com/transaction/a97a79864e78f668be6b35c7e3c75a556b782a3aa85f6c07a3d7c40748ed9ac5 https://tonviewer.com/transaction/b51bd48627d96331458389aff676818cf19fccedc2def707f00b87df19e71deb https://tonviewer.com/transaction/43ddf1e3c2ee9b5cd334d49554a90c99f3e7b0b52dbe22ba2e995149984503ce

The image shows the transaction confirmation in Tonkeeper. Tonkeeper_2024-11-20_02-16-41

omid2s commented 1 day ago

In this transaction, I was charged a higher fee(0.065 TON) than what the Tonkeeper wallet indicated(0.015 TON), and the transaction was not completed. I repeated the transaction three more times and it failed each time. Every transaction attempt resulted in a failure code of 48, witch apparently indicates an insufficient transaction fee. This is puzzling as I had a balance significantly higher than the required fee in my Tonkeeper wallet.

I expected the transaction to carry out or report the problem properly. But a few times it just charged me a fee without explaining why!

Phone OS: Android 13 TKQ1.221013.002 Wallet: Tonkeeper 5.0.15 (877) - v4R2

These are all my failed transactions: https://tonviewer.com/transaction/c2b6848c9f7344f3c8c7888dc5195a763be6fc51319aa43b928a3ff540655365 https://tonviewer.com/transaction/a97a79864e78f668be6b35c7e3c75a556b782a3aa85f6c07a3d7c40748ed9ac5 https://tonviewer.com/transaction/b51bd48627d96331458389aff676818cf19fccedc2def707f00b87df19e71deb https://tonviewer.com/transaction/43ddf1e3c2ee9b5cd334d49554a90c99f3e7b0b52dbe22ba2e995149984503ce

The image shows the transaction confirmation in Tonkeeper. Tonkeeper_2024-11-20_02-16-41

There can be several reasons. Hamster is not the only one. Most of them are network congestion. TON network is not fast as advertised. And then the token is not approved. When it comes time to distribute airdrop tokens, TON network acts like a turtle. The only way. At least wait a few days. This is what my experience in the transfer of several airdrop tokens says.

Saraylu commented 1 day ago

@omid2s It seems related to the HMSTR smart contract.