search

uphy / obsidian-reminder

Reminder plugin for Obsidian
https://uphy.github.io/obsidian-reminder/
MIT License
455 stars 35 forks source link

No time, no reminder #41

Closed mrkuramoto closed 2 years ago

mrkuramoto commented 3 years ago

Goal or desired outcome of this feature

I'd like to have an option to turn off notification for tasks without time. I have tried to leave the time of reminder blank in settings, but this app refused to accept it.

Describe the feature

Just a button to turn off notification for task without a specific time

Screenshots, mockups, or videos

No response

imed-ghomari commented 3 years ago

If you want a task with a date and no time, shouldn't you use the tasks plugin instead of the reminder plugin ?

uphy commented 3 years ago

I feel it is not a reminder but a due date. It should be in a different format because it has a different meaning.

Currently obsidian-reminder plugin supplies reminder feature. Therefore, unfortunately, I think your request is out of the scope of the plugin.

mrkuramoto commented 3 years ago

I feel it is not a reminder but a due date. It should be in a different format because it has a different meaning.

Currently obsidian-reminder plugin supplies reminder feature. Therefore, unfortunately, I think your request is out of the scope of the plugin.

I love the remind plugin, and I have been using it every day. I use it when I have time to make something, and I have a lot throughout the day. My request is the ability to turn off notifications for tasks that don't have time. I need to see them, but I don't need a pop-up reminder. For example, if I create ten tasks with no time, Reminder will deploy ten reminders that I don't need.

uphy commented 3 years ago

I'm very glad you use this plugin heavily!

My request is the ability to turn off notifications for tasks that don't have time.

Of course, I can implement the feature, but I think such a specific feature request is extremely rare. It may be useful for you, but we believe it will only complicate the plugin function for many people.

if I create ten tasks with no time, Reminder will deploy ten reminders that I don't need.

I think we should resolve THIS issue with another way.

For example,

mrkuramoto commented 3 years ago

Hi Yuhi, thank you for your prompt answer and I understood your comments. Thank you!