Consider conformance of HybridSign static text

[j-d-b]

Background

Currently, the static_sign_text property on the HybridSign object is optional. The property is described as:

The static text on the non-electronic component of the hybrid sign.

Issue

Members have asked several times why the static_sign_text is optional, and I couldn't find an answer in the specification documentation or my meeting notes. This issue seeks to start discussion that could lead to requiring this property in a future release.

Discussion

• Discuss the reasoning for representing a HybridSign without providing static_sign_text.
• Discuss if the static_sign_text property should be required.

[j-d-b]

For some initial thoughts:

Generally, WZDx tries to only make properties required that are critical to processing the data. For a hybrid sign, the only required property is dynamic_message_function, which is defined as:

The function the dynamic message displayed (e.g. a speed limit).

This can have a value of speed-limit, travel-time, or other. With speed-limit, the static_sign_text is not needed to know if what dynamic_message_text is used for. Perhaps this is why it is optional.

[sergebeaudry]

I agree that this could be required. I only see cases where some text exist on those. Speed Limit, Travel Time, height limit, width limit, etc....... Even the dynamic_message_text might be required with potential to call it blanked

[j-d-b]

Based on SWZ subgroup co-chairs discussion, static_sign_text should be required. Thus the proposed change in the meantime is to indicate in the documentation that the property will be required in a future release.

This issue will remain open until v5.0, when the property can be required.

[tfoster-vm]

Could it stay open for being required in v5.0 and also be added still be added as optional until v5.0?