search

w3c / did-extensions

Decentralized Identifier Ecosystem Extensions
https://w3c.github.io/did-extensions/
Other
120 stars 200 forks source link

DID Method Registration Resolution #2 on 2021-03-16 #271

Open OR13 opened 3 years ago

OR13 commented 3 years ago

Update the registration table to include, status, first registered date, last reviewed date

https://www.w3.org/2019/did-wg/Meetings/Minutes/2021-03-16-did-topic#resolution2

OR13 commented 3 years ago

I think the dates are a terrible idea, and we should close this issue and not implement this resolution... github tracks dates for us.

OR13 commented 3 years ago

we should resolve not to do this, and close the issue.

iherman commented 3 years ago

The issue was discussed in a meeting on 2021-08-17

List of resolutions:

View the transcript #### 6.5. DID Method Registration Resolution #2 on 2021-03-16 (issue did-spec-registries#271) _See github issue [did-spec-registries#271](https://github.com/w3c/did-spec-registries/issues/271)._ **Orie Steele:** Similar scenario, this was about status and dates … We can do status with labels, not sure what to do about dates … Either we need new proposals for handling dates, or decide that we will not implement the resolution **Manu Sporny:** We have a resolution for first registered date, and last reviewed date **Brent Zundel:** Seemed like a good idea at that time **Manu Sporny:** Not sure if this is very useful **Drummond Reed:** I still think "first registered" is a good idea, but "last reviewed" doesn't seem to make sense > *Markus Sabadello:* This can be reconstructed from Git history? **Ted Thibodeau Jr.:** This is also overtaken by events. … We registered DID methods before we had even finalized the requirements for DID methods. **Orie Steele:** We should just use Git, and resolve to not implement this resolution **Joe Andrieu:** The link that people click on may not be the one that was reviewed (unless we use hashlinks) **Brent Zundel:** There was a lot of conversation on liveness, and how up-to-date DID methods are. > **Proposed resolution: We are not going to add dates in a table to the DID Registry** *(Brent Zundel)* > *Ivan Herman:* +1 > *Manu Sporny:* +1 > *Brent Zundel:* +1 > *Drummond Reed:* +1 > *Orie Steele:* +1 > *Charles Lehner:* +1 > *Dave Longley:* +1 > *Shigeya Suzuki:* +1 > *Markus Sabadello:* +1 > *Ted Thibodeau Jr.:* +1 > ***Resolution #4: We are not going to add dates in a table to the DID Registry*** > *Drummond Reed:* Thanks Brent. Big high five to Joe and Daniel and also Orie. **Brent Zundel:** Thanks everyone, we got through a lot of items. Cu next time. ---