search

w3c / media-wg

Media Working Group
11 stars 12 forks source link

Moving video.requestVideoFrameCallback spec to media WG? #34

Closed tguilbert-google closed 2 years ago

tguilbert-google commented 2 years ago

I was recently asked to consider moving the video.requestVideoFrameCallback spec from WICG to the media WG.

How does the WG evaluate which specs it takes on? Could discussing this be a added to the agenda of the next media WG meeting?

Thank you!

chrisn commented 2 years ago

Thanks. The Media WG's charter says that we would need to re-charter to take on a new spec. I note that other specs that are closely related to HTML elements have moved from the Media WG to WHATWG - Media Playback Quality is an example, so that's another possible avenue.

We have a WG meeting coming up Tuesday 9 November at 22:00 UTC / 14:00 US Pacific. Would this time work for you?

tguilbert-google commented 2 years ago

Yes, I will attend that meeting. Thank you!

annevk commented 2 years ago

How would you resolve all the integration points that are needed with HTML? Wouldn't you be left with very little spec once that's all addressed?

domenic commented 2 years ago

The spec also says in its body "This spec should eventually be merged into the HTML spec"

tguilbert-google commented 2 years ago

I see... This might therefore be a better fit in the HTML spec directly?

+@youennf as an FYI

youennf commented 2 years ago

Going to the HTML spec looks ok to me. WebRTC/Media WG probably will want to have their say in the exposed metadata but this can happen in HTML repo as well.

chrisn commented 2 years ago

We discussed in yesterday's WG meeting and concluded that this should indeed be merged into the HTML spec.

tguilbert-google commented 2 years ago

Agreed. I am closing this issue, and will open one with the HTML WG shortly.