It stopped working after upgrade to Sonoma 14.4

zackelia / bclm

macOS command-line utility to limit max battery charge

MIT License

1.79k stars 87 forks source link

It stopped working after upgrade to Sonoma 14.4 #42

Open AlexeyBH opened 6 months ago

AlexeyBH commented 6 months ago

Hello,

I have MacBook Pro 16 M2 Max. Everything was okay before I updated MacOS to Sonoma 14.4 (23E214).

Since then, bclm stopped working. I tried to upgrade it using brew, but, unfortunately, it didn't help.

ahmtzrrcn commented 4 months ago

any updates on this?

AlexeyBH commented 4 months ago

any updates on this?

Unfortunately, it's the same.

IShinji commented 4 months ago

The current system version is Sonoma 14.5. The persist command is not working properly, and it becomes ineffective after a restart. MacBook Pro 13 M1

pencilheart commented 3 months ago

M2 14.5 works, clamshell mode and restart also work.

w0utert commented 2 months ago

M3 Max Sonoma 14.5 is not working anymore, the setting is not persisted even though bclm read does print 80 and bclm persist says 'Already persisting!'. Was working before.

zackelia commented 1 month ago

Not seeing this behavior on Sonoma 14.6.1, are others still having issues?

w0utert commented 1 month ago

@zackelia what I’m seeing is that if I do ‘bclm write 80’ then ‘bclm persist’ charging will indeed be limited to 80%, but only until I power down the laptop and reboot it. After the reboot ‘bclm read’ and ‘bclm persist’ will report the setting is still 80 percent and persisting, but connecting the laptop to power it will charge to 100% until I do ‘bclm write 80’ again.

zackelia commented 1 month ago

Can't replicate that on my end, charging behavior is what I expect. I'm not sure why there would be any difference for your case, the persist functionality is just doing that same bclm write 80 on startup. The weird thing is it sounds similar to this on Intel Macs https://github.com/zackelia/bclm/issues/13

w0utert commented 1 month ago

I can still reproduce this.

Connect laptop to charger (TB4 dock in my case)
Write 80% max charge using bclm write 80 and bclm persist => laptop will suspend charging at 80% as expected
Suspend laptop and leave for a while, wake => battery still exactly at 80%
Unplug laptop and use for a while to drain to e.g. ~60%
Fully powerdown laptop (so not sleep, but shut down) then plug in charger
Wait for a few hours, reboot, and see this: