search

zotero / zotero-bits

CSL-related community feedback for Zotero
56 stars 8 forks source link

Music Score #28

Open avram opened 13 years ago

avram commented 13 years ago

"ISMN"/ismn is the standard identifier. (new field)

Composer, librettist, lyricist as creator roles.

Existing fields to include: Publisher, (Publisher) Place, Series, Series Number, Date, ISBN, Pages, and the basics like Extra, Library Catalog, Archive, etc. Also existing creator roles: Editor, Translator, Contributor, Series Editor

See MusicScoreType on the wiki: https://github.com/ajlyon/zotero-bits/wiki/MusicScoreType

avram commented 13 years ago

The RIS translator has the comment: // TODO: DATA, MUSIC That is, we would like to support music scores (I think( for importing from RIS. Maybe someone can describe what Endnote puts in a music score item?

adam3smith commented 13 years ago

for mapping of creators: composer can map to author: it's never labeled in the examples. We have yet to see an example where librettist/lyricist would actually be cited, though I can definitely see that happening. Depending on that those would need to be new creator types or map to contributor.

avram commented 13 years ago

I've added two more sources to the wiki page. @rmzelle, @adam3smith, @bdarcus, @fbennett -- Is there any hope for distilling that down to one type? The italicization rules look particularly difficult to handle cleanly, and there's the issue of complete and partial works (like citing movements or symphonies).

adam3smith commented 13 years ago

These look very systematic, but fall into different categories (I've not bothered to mark-up italics, the examples are all from http://www.lib.uwo.ca/music/citemus.html) Book sections, e.g.: Claude Debussy, "Le vent dans la plaine," Préludes, ed. Pierre Marchand (Paris: Durand, ca. 1910), 8

and books

  1. Louise Talma, Pastoral Prelude (Boston: Carl Fischer, 1952), 5. [F] Talma, Louise. Pastoral Prelude. Boston: Carl Fischer, 1952. [B]

and in some cases even manuscript Gustav Mahler, "Symphony No. 1," copyist's score with annotations in Mahler's hand, ?1888-1889, CDN-Lu OS-MD-694, v.1-2. The Gustav Mahler-Alfred Rosé Collection, The Music Library, University of Western Ontario, London, ON, Canada.

I think I'm inclined to say we'll be better of not adding a separate item type, but instead including Composer and maybe Librettist as creator types - it would seem like we could flawlessly create all citation types that way.

gracile-fr commented 12 years ago

This link (provided on the forum) might be helpful too: http://libguides.is.uwa.edu.au/content.php?pid=174262&sid=1466478

adam3smith commented 11 years ago

see also this thread: http://forums.zotero.org/discussion/18979/translator-request-imslporg/#Item_14

bwiernik commented 4 years ago

Is there a need for ISMN as a CSL variable? If not, then there isn't a need for any CSL changes here.

denismaier commented 4 years ago

I think we should add ISMN, but let's discuss that in https://github.com/citation-style-language/csl-evolution/issues/39 and add the Zotero label here.