0neGal / viper

Launcher+Updater for TF|2 Northstar
https://0negal.github.io/viper
GNU General Public License v3.0
152 stars 21 forks source link

Update logo associated with Viper #44

Closed GeckoEidechse closed 2 years ago

GeckoEidechse commented 2 years ago

The issue with the current logo is that it is the same as the one NorthstarCN uses.

screenshot northstarcn github page

To avoid confusion the two projects (Viper and NorthstarCN) should probably use different logos. As NorthstarCN is closer in content to Northstar (it's just Northstar but with tweaks for the Chinese community) it makes more sense for the to use an icon that closely resembles that of Northstar.

Therefore I'd argue it would probably be best for Viper to use a different logo.

Either something else related to Northstar (the titan), like

hover ability

or

flight core

Or something related to Viper (the TF|2 character), like

viper helmet (Not my artwork)

That way the two projects should be better set apart and Viper would have it's own more individual look.

0neGal commented 2 years ago

Or something related to Viper (the TF|2 character)

Originally I actually did intend on making such an icon, but it was replaced by a "temporary" icon that is the current one, mostly because I'm bad at making icons...

I was actually planning on trying to make a flat-style icon today that looked like Viper's helmet.

From #2

I do think NorthstarCN should keep its icon, and would prefer something related to Viper himself and not Northstar, for obvious reasons :p

So if somebody who's better at making icons would be able to make one I'll gladly change it to it...

Alystrasz commented 2 years ago

I like the idea of using Viper's helmet. Maybe we can have something like Titanfall2's original icon?

Capture d’écran 2022-01-16 220201


Something in this style?

test

0neGal commented 2 years ago

Something in this style?

And of course with the body below it, perhaps we should then move the Northstar tab below the game tab or similar, as to have the two matching icons beside each other.

Alystrasz commented 2 years ago

More like this?


perhaps we should then move the Northstar tab below the game tab or similar, as to have the two matching icons beside each other.

I'm not so sure, I really think we should separate Viper stuff from game (Northstar/tf2) stuff, but you're already aware of this with the icons space story 😄

0neGal commented 2 years ago

More like this?

Precisely! Althought maybe make some space around the neck? like the original. If possible.

I'm not so sure, I really think we should separate Viper stuff from game

I would agree, on a UX level it makes far more sense to separate, but my need to satisfy looks often comes above that, it's not a set decision, and I'll likely end up keeping the current layout...

Alystrasz commented 2 years ago

Here's the GIMP project if you want to mess up with this: https://cloud.remyraes.com/s/MA46xGpftQH8zJ5 (password is P"CnUK79ny)

0neGal commented 2 years ago

This is my version of it:

As for yours I'm not sure the gradient really fits in, not just because the original icon doesn't have it, but also because at a distance it's not visible whatsoever. When it comes to my version I'm not sure whether to keep the helmet color and background the same.

However I used the red that we use for in the app...

Alystrasz commented 2 years ago

I'm not a designer anyways... Your version is sick!

Alystrasz commented 2 years ago

Btw, for proper crediting, I used https://www.reddit.com/r/titanfall/comments/6ndi7h/i_turned_usioells_simple_viper_graphic_into_a/ as source.

XNovaDelta commented 2 years ago

I have a concept based on the northstar launcher logo (I'm not a designer, sorry the non centered stuff, i used an even number of pixels without realizing it could cause that) It would fit with the launcher icons, maybe you could even include the NorthstarCN to avoid another fork (it seems that they have already forked the Viper launcher) maybe with a region selector on the initial launch.

Mesa de trabajo 1@4x

0neGal commented 2 years ago

I have a concept based on the northstar launcher logo

That actually looks really good!

maybe you could even include the NorthstarCN to avoid another fork (it seems that they have already forked the Viper launcher) maybe with a region selector on the initial launch.

We natively support translations and localizations, it's all up to them adding them.

XNovaDelta commented 2 years ago

I have a concept based on the northstar launcher logo (I'm not a designer, sorry the non centered stuff, i used an even number of pixels without realizing it could cause that) It would fit with the launcher icons, maybe you could even include the NorthstarCN to avoid another fork (it seems that they have already forked the Viper launcher) maybe with a region selector on the initial launch.

Here's the Illustrator .ai if you want to use it (the color of choice was because of viper's visor, btw)

NS.zip

XNovaDelta commented 2 years ago

I have a concept based on the northstar launcher logo

That actually looks really good!

Thank you!

maybe you could even include the NorthstarCN to avoid another fork (it seems that they have already forked the Viper launcher) maybe with a region selector on the initial launch.

We natively support translations and localizations, it's all up to them adding them.

What I meant is that you could implement downloading the normal Northstar launcher and the NorthstarCN fork at the same time (not talking about translations) that way you could have the final Viper logo (looking similar to the NS launcher like the design I made) besides the Normal NS Launcher and the Chinese Fork logo looking all good and you could avoid a fork of Viper that can cause more segmentation. (i know this is a logo issue, but I'm thinking if you implement that function) and the CN fork dev team can just commit to the viper's repo instead for downloading their fork of Viper.

XNovaDelta commented 2 years ago

I made some changes, and in gray scale with orange "shadows", here's the zip with the .ai files too!

Viper Logo.zip

With neck: Mesa de trabajo 1WN

Without neck: Mesa de trabajo 1WON

With neck grayscale: Mesa de trabajo 1WNGS

Without neck grayscale Mesa de trabajo 1WONGS

0neGal commented 2 years ago

Orange without neck is the one I prefer of those 4...

XNovaDelta commented 2 years ago

Here's a preview of the icon in use with the launcher

image

58 also showing the spanish locale working and looking ok

XNovaDelta commented 2 years ago

I corrected a defect in the right side of the helmet in the logo:

512x512

How should i go about trying to help with the logo? should i just keep updating progress here? should i make a PR with the logo and vector?

0neGal commented 2 years ago

Given that there's no actual code being changed I'd much prefer if you just let me know when you're where you feel the logo is done, and of course feel free to post progress... When done I'll make the PR updating all the assets to the new logo :)

XNovaDelta commented 2 years ago

I'm going to upload the final files in a moment, but first i want to ask if i should license it unde CC SA, Public domain or just don't bother at all with licensing?

0neGal commented 2 years ago

... but first i want to ask if i should license it unde CC SA, Public domain or just don't bother at all with licensing?

Given that it's inside this repository, it automatically inherits the repo's license (GPLv3), hence no license, I'm assuming this is some metadata Illustrator allows to put on the image? In that case no license.

Generally contributing to an open source repository you automatically accept that your work will be submitted under the repo's license. Anything we can't put under the license we have to credit and specify (See the Credits section)

Hope that makes sense...

XNovaDelta commented 2 years ago

Ok, i asked because i thought that gpl just covered code and not assets. If you want to change anything, just tell me and i'll be glad to make the changes!

512x512

Here's the final version

Here's the zip with the files

Viper Icon.zip