0xPolygonMiden / compiler

Compiler from MidenIR to Miden Assembly
MIT License
61 stars 20 forks source link

Namespace of the compiled MASM module for the Rust code #208

Closed greenhat closed 6 days ago

greenhat commented 3 months ago

The compiler produces compilation artifacts in a form of one MASM file per module using module ID for the file name. The Rust code resides in a module with an ID corresponding to the crate name. If we load the MASM module without specifying the namespace, it gets assigned a #anon namespace. But I cannot figure out the way to call the procedure from the module with #anon namespace. I've tried to call the procedure without importing the module assuming the #anon namespace is the default one, but it doesn't work. I've tried the use directive with the #anon namespace, but it doesn't work either. At the end I went with a workaround by assigning a synthetic namespace user_ns to the module, but the DX is not ideal.

greenhat commented 2 months ago

Procedures from anonymously parsed modules should be callable after https://github.com/0xPolygonMiden/miden-vm/pull/1363 is merged.

bitwalker commented 2 months ago

To elaborate a bit on how we should address this once 1363 is merged:

I'm planning a subsequent expansion of the path syntax in the assembler so that Wasm Component Model identifiers are also valid Miden Assembly identifiers, e.g. exec.::miden:tx-kernel/get-inputs would be parsed as ProcedurePath::Absolute with a path given by LibraryPath::new_from_components(LibraryNamespace::User("miden"), ["tx-kernel".into()]), and a name given by Ident::new("get-inputs"). This would be able to be combined with other options, such as raw procedure name identifiers, to allow for things like exec.::foo:bar/"baz::<T>::new".

That change I'll land after 0xPolygonMiden/miden-vm#1363, but at the moment we don't have packages, so we can get away without it since we don't need to reference items in other Wasm-compiled modules yet. For the time being, we can simply make use of what is provided in 1363 to handle referencing items much more seamlessly.

bobbinth commented 2 months ago

I'm planning a subsequent expansion of the path syntax in the assembler so that Wasm Component Model identifiers are also valid Miden Assembly identifiers, e.g. exec.::miden:tx-kernel/get-inputs would be parsed as ProcedurePath::Absolute with a path given by LibraryPath::new_from_components(LibraryNamespace::User("miden"), ["tx-kernel".into()]), and a name given by Ident::new("get-inputs"). This would be able to be combined with other options, such as raw procedure name identifiers, to allow for things like exec.::foo:bar/"baz::<T>::new".

As mentioned on the call, we could also consider making this the canonical way to define paths in MASM. So:

use.std:math::u64

begin
    exec.u64/add
end

Would be the same as:

begin
    exec.std:math::u64/add
end

And in both cases, the absolute path would be:

LibraryPath::new_from_components(LibraryNamespace::User("std"), ["math".into(), "u64".into()])

The primary motivation for this would be to reduce the complexity in the assembler at the cost of introducing some breaking changes (which I think may be OK).


Separately, we should probably rename LibraryPath::new_from_components() into just LibraryPath::from_components() to be consistent with how things are usually named in Rust.

bitwalker commented 6 days ago

Closing as completed for now. The assembler refactoring has made this largely redundant, though there are still improvements we can make to paths/identifiers in MASM.