search

0xbb / gpu-switch

gpu-switch is an application that allows to switch between the graphic cards of dual-GPU Macbook Pro models
MIT License
537 stars 57 forks source link

gpu-switch -i causes computer to just freeze on osx 10.12.4 #39

Open adityaravishankar opened 7 years ago

adityaravishankar commented 7 years ago

Just got the latest code off github and ran the build script.

Freshly booted laptop with gfxCardStatus running in the background.

Running ./gpu-switch -i caused the computer to freeze completely.

Any advice would be helpful.

Model: MacBookPro8,2 OS: macOS Sierra 10.12.4

Happy to share/add further debugging/logging information as needed, to help with fixing this issue.

0xbb commented 7 years ago

I don't have access to a MacBook anymore and I can't help you with this issue. But I am not sure if gpu-switch should be run together with gfxCardStatus.

rythmkraze commented 7 years ago

Same issue here. Running ./gpu-switch -i freezes the computer. No gfxCardStatus running in the background. But gfxCardStatus also exhibits the same behaviour, that is switching to "integrated only" freezes the computer.

Model Identifier: MacBookPro8,2 OS: macOS Sierra 10.12.4 (16E195)

ah- commented 7 years ago

I suspect this is due to changes Apple made in 10.12.4. switcher/gfxCardStatus call a private API, and the one to switch GPU in particular hasn't been in use by the official energy saver preference pane for a long time now (if it ever was, don't quite remember).

I guess this call is just broken now and there's not a whole lot we can do about it. Someone with a lot of time would need to go and look if there's a new alternative way to switch to internal only mode.

rythmkraze commented 7 years ago

Thanks @ah- for the quick response. Looks like I am out of luck then :(

codedmart commented 7 years ago

Not sure if my issue is related. I have been using gpu-switch for a while just fine, but noticed since the upgrading to 10.12.4 I can't get my integrated card to work in Linux. I see it as powered off when I cat vgaswitcheroo, but if I try to switch to it I just get a blank screen now. When I run ./gpu-switch -i my system doesn't freeze though.

codedmart commented 7 years ago

@0xbb Anyway I can help with getting this to work with Sierra 10.12.4?

codedmart commented 7 years ago

@ah- Any way I can help with progress on this?

ah- commented 7 years ago

@codedmart could you try getting some log output from dmesg during/after the switch to a blank screen? Either by ssh-ing in or switching back blindly? Ideally with drm.debug=0x06 set to get a bit more verbose output if there's nothing clear in dmesg otherwise.

And so gpu-switch -i still works for you (on linux)? Does it actually boot up with the integrated card?

codedmart commented 7 years ago

@ah- I don't get any errors in OSX when running gpu-switch -i, and when I boot into linux I do see the integrated card, but I can't get it to work anymore (just the blank screen). It use to work fine before 10.12.4. I will try to dump some output from dmesg.

ah- commented 7 years ago

Has your linux kernel changed since it worked?

I'm just looking for any hint in the logs if it detects a screen at all and if the resolution is correct etc.

codedmart commented 7 years ago

I don't think it is kernel related because I tried various kernels I had between upgrades, but I could be wrong. I will get more output as soon as I can.