10Groups / 10groups.github.io

10Groups is a political test that measures one's political beliefs on 10 Different Categories.
https://10groups.github.io/
Other
23 stars 10 forks source link

The axis weight for many questions is wrong #13

Open Aashishkebab opened 1 year ago

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago

For example:

{"id": 4, "question": "A free economy is the best tool for establishing wages and the price of labour.", "effects": {"y": -5, "ay": 5}},

If you agree with this question, it slants the a graph to more "regulated", which makes no sense. It should be "ay": -5 like the other ones.

There are several examples of wrong ones. Sometimes it's the wrong x vs y, and sometimes it's the wrong direction. I'll file a PR with the values corrected.

Several questions also have typos/misspellings.

EDIT: Please see #14.

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago

Actually this entire section is super wrong. All the values should be positive:

{"id": 88, "question": "Technology is negatively affecting modern society.", "effects": {"ex": -5}}, {"id": 89, "question": "The Industrial Revolution and its consequences have been a disaster for the human race.", "effects": {"ex": -5}}, {"id": 90, "question": "Usage of genetic modification for animals and plants should be minimized.", "effects": {"ex": -5}}, {"id": 91, "question": "Modernity and social progress has led to a decrease of happiness, and often lacks meaning.", "effects": {"ex": -5}},

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago

Same with all these:

//Cultural Hierarchy - Hierarchy {"id": 118, "question": "Even though equal opportunities can lead to equal outcomes, society should still focus on equal opportunities, and not equal outcomes.", "effects": {"gx": -5}}, {"id": 119, "question": "Hierarchies will inevitably be formed in every society, at any time.", "effects": {"gx": -5}}, {"id": 120, "question": "Any well-functioning society requries a hierarchy.", "effects": {"gx": -5}},

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago

I mean, here's the whole code block for cultural hierarchy:

//Cultural Hierarchy - Equality {"id": 116, "question": "A system of equal outcomes should be established.", "effects": {"gx": -5}}, {"id": 117, "question": "People should be treated equally regardless of their groups and characteristics.", "effects": {"gx": -5}}, //Cultural Hierarchy - Hierarchy {"id": 118, "question": "Even though equal opportunities can lead to equal outcomes, society should still focus on equal opportunities, and not equal outcomes.", "effects": {"gx": -5}}, {"id": 119, "question": "Hierarchies will inevitably be formed in every society, at any time.", "effects": {"gx": -5}}, {"id": 120, "question": "Any well-functioning society requries a hierarchy.", "effects": {"gx": -5}},

They can't all be -5. That should be clear indication that they are very wrong.

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago

Also what does this have to do with collectivism vs individualism?

{"id": 142, "question": "If the current career system is being used, a person's personal and work life should stay seperate.", "effects": {"ja": 5}},

You can be individualistic and still tie your work life into your personal life.

EDIT: I changed/re-worded this qurstion.

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago

I'm not sure about the calculations either. It seems it's impossible to score the extreme in some cases, especially the bars. I answered 100% idealistic in my responses and yet only scored about 2/3rds of the way to idealism.

EDIT: The dots were being drawn in the wrong place.

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago

{"id": 55, "question": "If I were to support international organizations at all, I will only support international organizations that align with my political beliefs.", "effects": {"cy": 5}},

What does this have to do with nationalism?

EDIT: I re-worded this.

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago
{"id": 50, "question": "Technology that improves mental and physical capabilities shouldn't be used, in any political system.", "effects": {"ey": 5}},
//Technological Transhumanism - Primitivism
{"id": 51, "question": "Technology that improves mental and physical capabilities shouldn't be used, in any political system.", "effects": {"ey": -5}},

This question is repeated, and yet has opposite weights...

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago

{"id": 149, "question": "An eye for eye and a tooth for tooth.", "effects": {"jd": 5}},

That is NOT deontology.

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago

I know it says it's a work in progress, but this section of the graph is just extremely wrong:

image
Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago
document.getElementById("mor-a").value = (10 - (ix_axis / 1.05));
document.getElementById("mor-b").value = (10 - (iy_axis / 1.05));
document.getElementById("mor-c").value = (10 - (ix_axis / 1.05));
document.getElementById("mor-d").value = (10 - (iy_axis / 1.05));

This section of code makes no sense. The four last axes bars have the same names and yet different values than the ones in the top image, and also two are just copying each other.

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago
<div class="center"><div class="label-l"><label for="pol-a">Radical</label></div>
<progress id="pol-a" value="10" max="20"> </progress>
<div class="label-r"><label for="pol-a">Moderate</label></div> </div>

<div class="center"><div class="label-l"><label for="pol-b">Politicized</label></div>
<progress id="pol-b" value="10" max="20"> </progress>
<div class="label-r"><label for="pol-b">Apolitical</label></div> </div>

These aren't even referenced at all.

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago
#dipl-a::-webkit-progress-value, #dipl-b::-webkit-progress-value, #dipl-c::-webkit-progress-value, #dipl-d::-webkit-progress-value, #dipl-e::-webkit-progress-value {
    background: #AFEEEE;   
}  
#dipl-a::-moz-progress-bar, #dipl-b::-moz-progress-bar, #dipl-c::-moz-progress-bar, #dipl-d::-moz-progress-bar, #dipl-e::-moz-progress-bar {
    background: #B0C4DE;   
}  
#dipl-a::-webkit-progress-value, #dipl-b::-webkit-progress-value, #dipl-c::-webkit-progress-value, #dipl-d::-webkit-progress-value, #dipl-e::-webkit-progress-value {
    background: #AFEEEE;  
}  
#dipl-a::-webkit-progress-bar, #dipl-b::-webkit-progress-bar, #dipl-c::-webkit-progress-bar, #dipl-d::-webkit-progress-bar, #dipl-e::-webkit-progress-bar {
    background: #B0C4DE;    
}

Webkit progress value is used twice for all items in axes.css, should be moz.

Aashishkebab commented 1 year ago

Also the indentation in the files is lacking.