[Question] Difference to thephpleague/flysystem-bundle

[michaelKaefer]

Could someone explain to me why there are two bundles for the same cause? What is the difference to thephpleague/flysystem-bundle? Which one should we use? Sorry for posting it as an issue but I don't know where else I could ask.

[bytehead]

See https://github.com/1up-lab/OneupFlysystemBundle/pull/190 and the discussion on twitter https://twitter.com/Majkl578/status/1119272779856195584. It's up to you which to use, can't give you an unbiased opinion here 😉

[michaelKaefer]

To sum it up it up for further readers who have the same question: 1up-lab/OneupFlysystemBundle was released 2017 and has about 5,100,000 downloads on packagist in January 2020. Without explaining the reason another bundle was released in 2019, named league/flysystem-bundle with 200,000 downloads. On Twitter (see the link in the comment above) one of the creators of the new bundle did not answer the question on why the new bundle was built. But he claims that it is the official bundle here and Flysystem claims the same here. But Symfony does nowhere say which one is official as far as I found out and in Symfonycasts they use 1up-lab/OneupFlysystemBundle. So in short: I found no good reason why league/flysystem-bundle should replace 1up-lab/OneupFlysystemBundle.

Update: in the book "Symfony 5: The fast track" only league/flysystem-bundle is mentioned (at the end of step 14).

[michaelKaefer]

I asked the same question on the other side: https://github.com/thephpleague/flysystem-bundle/issues/37

[tgalopin]

Hello,

Please feel free to use the OneUpFlysystemBundle. It's a great bundle.

Official in my article means I have discussed it with the author of Flysystem in order to create a better integration between Flysystem and Symfony than what was possible before. It is official as it is under the PHPLeague umbrella, not from Symfony POV.

Note: I tend to dislike the tone and lack of question of your message. It does not invite to discuss in a sensible way about technology and instead rely on preconceived ideas you have. I'll continue working on trying to improve the open-source Symfony ecosystem and I usually ignore such messages. If you have question, feel free to reach me.

Note 2: I'm answering your questions on your other issue.

[michaelKaefer]

I am sorry for my tone, maybe it was to rude. And thank you for the clearification.

[stale[bot]]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.