Overpass API on relationships not working -

[HikeAndMap]

What is the bug?

I'm not sure if it's a bug or maybe I don't understand the syntax - but - if I want to show relationships at overpass-turbo.eu and it works there flawlessly I get exactly what I expect and copy that to the QuickOSM query - then I don't get what I expect.

That's why I think it's a bug, but again, maybe I'm using the wrong syntax.

So I go to https://overpass-turbo.eu/ and there I enter the query:

[out:json][timeout:25];

{{geocodeArea:Baguio,Cordillera Administrative Region}}->.searchArea;

(
  rel[ref][!route](area.searchArea);
);

out body;
>;
out skel qt;

Shows me exactly what I expect to see (look especially for the area at "City Camp Proper") the relationships that have the "ref" key are shown.

Now I go to the QuickOSM and copy that exact piece of query-code

I get now in yellow "successful query but no result"

The weird thing is - the ways part of the relationship - I add there any tag.. literally anything.. even just something crap like blabla=abcd et voila , now it shows that way as a result for my query of the relationships that have "ref" key.

This shouldn't be I think - if no tags are on the way/node but the way/node are part of a relationship I'm querying, the should return as a result.

Note I noiced this already months ago also on administrative boundaries.. relationships are NOT being shown if the way/node themselves which are part of the relationship have no tags at all.

And please keep in mind, the overpass-turbo.eu website does this very well, it shows relationships and their corresponding ways and nodes - even if those nodes and ways themselves are without tags.

Environment

Windows 11 - 64 bit QGIS: 3.30.2 (but again, this is already for months even in older versions) QuickOSM plugin version: 2.2.2

[Gustry]

Hi,

Shows me exactly what I expect to see (look especially for the area at "City Camp Proper") the relationships that have the "ref" key are shown.

Please share some HTTP links next time. It helps a lot to understand what you are looking for.

Are you talking about this relation for instance ? https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/16059099 So you are referring to this tagging scheme : https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Relation:multipolygon#Multiple_ways_forming_a_ring ?

QuickOSM is relying on OGR for OSM data parsing : https://gdal.org/drivers/vector/osm.html

And please keep in mind, the overpass-turbo.eu website does this very well, it shows relationships and their corresponding ways and nodes - even if those nodes and ways themselves are without tags.

Yes, but there are a lot of differences between overpass turbo and GIS. There are a few warnings on some OQL queries when they are run within QGIS because of some incompatibilities. But not this particular query indeed.

[HikeAndMap]

Are you talking about this relation for instance ? https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/16059099

yes