search

ANadig / YellowFruit

QB Stats App
14 stars 7 forks source link

Header for Standings report has redundant information when uploading reports to HSQB database #68

Open ani-per opened 5 days ago

ani-per commented 5 days ago

When adding reports to the HSQB database, the information contained in the header for the Standings report (tournament name, date, location, set name) is already in the HSQB database entry and is displayed at the top of the page on each report (except for set name, but that's available at the main entry). I think this information is still valuable to contain in the .yft file, just stating that printing it in the header there may be unnecessary.

jonahgreenthal commented 5 days ago

I don't think YellowFruit's HTML output should assume that it's only for display on hsquizbowl.org; it should be useful when posted anywhere, and "useful" entails the inclusion of basic metadata like the tournament name. If anything, perhaps hsquizbowl.org should filter its uploads and/or modify its display so as to eliminate redundancy.

ani-per commented 5 days ago

I don't think YellowFruit's HTML output should assume that it's only for display on hsquizbowl.org; it should be useful when posted anywhere, and "useful" entails the inclusion of basic metadata like the tournament name. If anything, perhaps hsquizbowl.org should filter its uploads and/or modify its display so as to eliminate redundancy.

Yes, I agree fully. Just wanted to bring this to Andrew's attention in case he considers HSQB to be the primary use case. This could also be a configurable option with printing being the default.