search

APSL / docker-thumbor

Docker image for thumbor. Detectors, optimizers, lazy detection and separate docker for remotecv.
MIT License
292 stars 110 forks source link

Is this project alive? #103

Open gingerlime opened 5 years ago

gingerlime commented 5 years ago

Hey @eduherraiz. Thanks again for creating this repo and maintaining it for a long time. However, it seems like it's no longer maintained for some time now, yet it is still linked to from several places, and it's also ranking high on docker hub for obvious reasons.

Of course, the code here is still useful, but it's likely to lead more people to run outdated versions of thumbor, which would later make upgrades more difficult. If they run into trouble, there's no one to help them.

I actively maintain https://github.com/MinimalCompact/thumbor (together with @kkopachev, who is a core member of the thumbor project as well). And I even try to help people who post questions here from time to time.

Could you archive this project or mark it as no-longer-maintained and link to https://github.com/MinimalCompact/thumbor ? I think it would help you with less noise, and users to find a more actively maintained project.

Of course, if you plan to resume maintenance then I'd be happy to contribute or bring the changes I've made on MinimalCompact into here.

Cheers, Yoav

eduherraiz commented 2 years ago

Thank you for the comment and sorry for the long delay of the answer.

Is alive again!

We have a work done trying to upgrade the thumbor on this image and some changes. I'm preparing a new release and consider to contribute in anyway on the future. I'll take a look of your fork!

gingerlime commented 2 years ago

Hi @eduherraiz ! welcome back from the dead.

I've been maintaining https://github.com/MinimalCompact/thumbor for over two years now, with support from the thumbor core team (@kkopachev and others). I believe that now https://github.com/MinimalCompact/thumbor is the de-facto standard docker distribution for thumbor. It's not a direct fork of your project, but it definitely used some of the ideas you started with ... but it's come a long way since.

I would suggest that at this point you join forces with us and contribute to our project. I think it will avoid fragmenting the community and duplicating work unnecessarily. We already started working on Thumbor 7 as well ... and of course supporting the latest 6.x versions.

eduherraiz commented 2 years ago

Hi @gingerlime! Thank you!

This project was not completly dead, we have some internal work done in our image but was not released properly. There is some docker tags ready to use on the hub.

I was looking yesterday in your image and you did an awesome work this two years:

At this moment my objective is upgrade our image for internal purposes, and I have a new version with 6.7.5 ready to test. But now, looking your job, I'm considering not publish the new release and archive this project like you propose. Let me check and test your image and I will write here my conclusions.