AUTOMATIC1111 / stable-diffusion-webui-extensions

Extension index for stable-diffusion-webui
502 stars 266 forks source link

[rq]request add sd-webui-decadetw-auto-messaging-realtime #362

Closed xlinx closed 3 months ago

xlinx commented 3 months ago

Info

please review: https://github.com/xlinx/sd-webui-decadetw-auto-messaging-realtime thx

Checklist:

w-e-w commented 3 months ago

is there a reason why you wouldn't just use a remote desktop

xlinx commented 3 months ago

Here are some ideas for you to consider:

w-e-w commented 3 months ago

nope not convinced in fact less convinced


if this is the use case then use the remote desktop it's better in every way

great I'm very lazy so I'm going to watch screenshots on the instant message apps it's going to be so entertaining this is sarcasm

just because it can be used as a log doesn't mean that you should use this as log there are better ways of making a log if you really need to

just tell me what sort of strange use case with group chat teamwork need screenshots and other information you sent on the regular basis

I'm not going to merge it to the index because I don't endorse it

the only time that a screenshot is actually useful is when you're sitting in front of a computer and if you're sitting in front of computer you don't need a screenshot if you need to send a then screenshot then take a screenshot manually when you're aware of the contents

I basically see zero case for your extension and for those niche situations that it might be useful therefore better ways of implementing it then the way you did it


if you truly think this is useful go ahead continue development don't let me stop you but as of now I can't see that this is a good idea so I'm not going to endorse it and I'm not going to put it on the index if it turns out that I'm wrong and that this extension does indeed have a wide user base then you can resubmitted to index

xlinx commented 3 months ago

@w-e-w okay, thank for the review, please le me provide a usage situstion recently. Im a teacher, which i made this is for students ro others non-IT base user ex: architect. More and more students use webui creating the school projects but they doesnt have the CARD, which mean they need use school computer. I saw a university of arts student render the combine of animdiff in sd-webui, she work on art-project in the school computers room, that need take care the result about every around 45mins. Mostly school has firewall so the remotedesktop are not work well. and also more and more remote desktop are not free now, include teamview(firewall issue, not free) anydesk(firewall issue, free for 5min) realvnc(not free now), rustdesktop(firewall issue). The skill of ssh tunnel through firewall is beyond them background knowledge, so i recommand use IM notify to do these. Anyway thanks for your analysis and review, truly.

w-e-w commented 3 months ago

why don't your students just use --share it connects to gradio server and it creates a tunnel and give you a link that can be accessed easily anywhere in the world without hassle there's nothing goes wrong the link should stay alive for 72 hours which is generally long enough for casual use


status notification through instant messaging apps might be useful in some use cases I will give you that but I was to argue this is a very thin use case especially if what you are sending is screenshots

if you want remote access to result you can also configure you will be it output to a directory that will be synced to a cloud storage using some sort of cloud storage sync software it's a software exist on your system you don't even need an extension to achieve this, you just can just configure webui to output to cloud sync directory

if you really want to have access to the results remotely through IM it makes much more sense to send the actual image you then sent a screenshot if they only wish to be notified then a text, to let you know that a long job has finished sure maybe useful but not a screenshot, screenshot is only useful if the screen is currently displaying useful information and the only gives you a slight preview of the final task job screenshot can even be potentially dangerous if you have sensitive information on screen at the time of the screenshot

xlinx commented 3 months ago

This ext provide 1.sd-image 2.sd-text 3. PC-state ex: cpu gpu temp. 4 screenshot will be canceled, which is security issue. In fact... when i try to find the best way to capture tempture on linux win os, but not found the good method, so use thescreenshot... I will delete it. Thx for the review in many detail.