AY2425S1-CS2103T-W11-3 / tp

MIT License
0 stars 5 forks source link

[PE-D][Tester D] Target user is too broad for the specifications of the product. #278

Open nus-se-script opened 9 hours ago

nus-se-script commented 9 hours ago

image.png It is mentioned in the DG that the target users comprises of

people who work in management/administration of tuition centres

This broad scope leads to a few issues regarding input validation.

  1. NRIC This param seems to be of Singaporean IC format and may not be applicable to users who are located overseas managing tuition centres abroad.

  2. YEAR_GROUP This param may not apply directly to foreign students where the primary and secondary school years are defined differently.

I feel that the product does not fully support potential target users and as such it is a feature flaw with medium severity. I think you can consider either making the target user more focused or tweak the features to be more accomodating.


Labels: severity.Medium type.FeatureFlaw original: wes-w-z-h/ped#4

JoanneHing commented 8 hours ago
  1. Explain why we set NRIC as we targeting local tuition centre, even for international student who is studying here long term should has a valid NRIC(FIN) with student pass. Maybe can also consider include in enhancement that we will allow more form of NRIC in the upcoming future.

  2. Same thing, we are targeting local tuition centre rather than other nation tuition.

maybe can update the DG and target user to emphasize Singapore Local tuition centres.