AcademySoftwareFoundation / tac

Materials and meeting notes for the ASWF Technical Advisory Council (TAC)
https://tac.aswf.io
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
94 stars 30 forks source link

ReadTheDocs inventory #672

Open jmertic opened 2 months ago

jmertic commented 2 months ago

We want to get an inventory of all the projects using ReadTheDocs for documentation and put two things in place...

1) Add the user releng-aswf to each RTDs account as a maintainer. This ensures the LF team can access the instance if everyone else is locked out. 2) Use each project's domain name to create a more uniform URL. For example, docs.opencolorio.org vs. opencolorio.readthedocs.io. Any previous *.readthedocs.io domain will be forwarded to the custom domain.

Project releng-aswf added Custom Domain active
OpenRV Yes No
xstudio Yes No
Imath Yes No
OpenColorIO Yes No
openexr Yes No
openfx Yes No
OpenImageIO Yes No
Open Shading Language Yes No
rez Yes No
OpenTimelineIO No No

Projects not using ReadTheDocs

JeanChristopheMorinPerso commented 2 months ago

Rez uses it, see https://rez.readthedocs.io.

aclark4life commented 2 months ago

As does OpenEXR https://openexr.com/en/latest/ FYI @cary-ilm

carolalynn commented 2 months ago

As does OCIO https://opencolorio.readthedocs.io/en/latest/

lgritz commented 2 months ago

OpenImageIO and Open Shading Language both use it: https://openimageio.readthedocs.io https://open-shading-language.readthedocs.io

garyo commented 2 months ago

OpenFX uses it: https://openfx.readthedocs.io

jmertic commented 1 month ago

Hi everyone! Great to see RTDs used so prevalently.

Two things I'd like to put in motion...

1) Add the user releng-aswf to each of your RTDs accounts as a maintainer. This ensures the LF team can access the instance in the event of everyone else being locked out. 2) I'd like to leverage each project's domain name to have a more uniform-style URL. So for example, docs.opencolorio.org vs opencolorio.readthedocs.io.

If everyone could do (1), our team can help on doing (2) for the project. Note the former URLs will redirect to the new domain.

LMK what everyone thinks!

garyo commented 1 month ago

releng-aswf now invited to openfx (https://openfx.readthedocs.io/en/latest/). We have quite a few references to the readthedocs.io URL on the site and in the code, so once it's switched we'll have some work to do (even if it redirects, we'll want to update to the correct URL).

JeanChristopheMorinPerso commented 1 month ago

releng-aswf added as maintainer of rez.readthedocs.io. For the domain name, what do we do with projects which don't have a home page like OCIO have? Rez has https://rez-project.io/ which redirects to our repo, but we don't actively promote that URL...

jmertic commented 1 month ago

For the domain name, what do we do with projects which don't have a home page like OCIO have? Rez has https://rez-project.io/ which redirects to our repo, but we don't actively promote that URL...

It's up to the project; I'd say keep that pointing to the repo and then docs.rez-project.io pointing to the docs. But we could also have the root domain forward to the docs subdomain too.

lgritz commented 1 month ago

releng-aswf added as maintainer for openimageio and open-shading-language.

I like the idea of making docs.openimageio.org work, but I hope that in the process we can still let openimageio.readthedocs.org work or redirect or something, because there are a lot of docs and old releases that publicize the old address, we've used it for years.

For OSL, I don't care, because our switch to RTD is recent and perhaps still experimental, so I don't think there is any significant switching cost to using a different URL going forward.

cary-ilm commented 1 month ago

OpenEXR uses readthedocs for the entire https://openexr.com website, since pretty much everything we have is documentation. It's fine to have docs.openexr.org redirect, but I'd prefer to keep the site as is, so the documentation pages show up under openexr.com.

I'm open to another configuration, but when I pondered this a while back, I really didn't see a great benefit in drawing a distinction between the "website" and the "documentation". I had a hard enough time sorting out the distinction between the website and the repo markdown.

reinecke commented 1 month ago

OpenTimelineIO is using readthedocs here: https://opentimelineio.readthedocs.io/en/stable/

@jminor @ssteinbach - I may not actually be setup to admin the RTD project, could one of you address the ask from @jmertic?

jmertic commented 1 month ago

I like the idea of making docs.openimageio.org work, but I hope that in the process we can still let openimageio.readthedocs.org work or redirect or something, because there are a lot of docs and old releases that publicize the old address, we've used it for years.

Yep @lgritz - it will keep the old URL and redirect to the new one.

jmertic commented 1 month ago

OpenEXR uses readthedocs for the entire https://openexr.com website, since pretty much everything we have is documentation. It's fine to have docs.openexr.org redirect, but I'd prefer to keep the site as is, so the documentation pages show up under openexr.com.

I'm open to another configuration, but when I pondered this a while back, I really didn't see a great benefit in drawing a distinction between the "website" and the "documentation". I had a hard enough time sorting out the distinction between the website and the repo markdown.

I think that makes sense - it would be good to have docs.openexr.com work as a valid subdomain just for the convention, but completely good with it redirecting to openexr.com. I think the biggest thing is I'd like to see these fancy domain names we have for everyone's projects put to good use :-).

tykeal commented 1 month ago

Ok, we've accepted invites from openfx, OpenImageIO, Open Shading Language, and rez.

Still waiting to see invites on other projects. Also, please post here when you send the invite. The invitations seem to be going to SPAM for some reason :-/ so I had to go hunting for them.

jmertic commented 1 month ago

Actions:

carolalynn commented 1 month ago

Doug added the releng-aswf account to OCIO's RTD account.

cary-ilm commented 1 month ago

I added releng-aswf to OpenEXR and Imath

tykeal commented 1 month ago

Thank you @carolalynn and @cary-ilm we've accepted those invites.

jmertic commented 1 month ago

Hi! I've updated the ticket description to track progress. Actions:

Thanks everyone!