search

Accord-Project / aec3po

AEC3PO: Architecture, Engineering, Construction Compliance Checking and Permitting Ontology
https://w3id.org/lbd/aec3po/
2 stars 1 forks source link

relate permitting_stages to standards and DiCon stages? #34

Closed VladimirAlexiev closed 1 year ago

VladimirAlexiev commented 1 year ago

Our permitting_stages are related to a territory (eg UK), but not to a standard. If I understand correctly, this is only an example, not an exhaustive list. https://github.com/Accord-Project/aec3po/blob/5fb6f7e2b8b9f0f208caeeab68461aa8b3c0dfcd/src/vocabularies/permitting_stages.ttl#L9-L15

https://digitalconstruction.github.io/Stages/v/0.5/ (dicstg:) defines stages according to some standards: BS_EN_16310, HOAI, ISO_22263, RIBA. In particular there is BS_EN_Regulatory_approval, HOAI_BuildingPermissionApplication. Should we relate our stages to standards and/or DiCon stages?

cc @beachtom

beachtom commented 1 year ago

The UK will generally follow RIBA stage - so I think relating to a standard is a good idea - but each pilot may wish to relate to a different standard

EdliraK commented 1 year ago

Yes, would be good to link to a standard. We don't have such a thing so far. @AmnaKRDB please keep a note to explore this at least for the UK. We would need to ask other countries how they deal with this.

VladimirAlexiev commented 1 year ago

The RIBA stages are RIBA_ConceptDesign RIBA_Construction RIBA_DevelopedDesign RIBA_HandoverandCloseout RIBA_InUse RIBA_PreparationandBrief RIBA_StrategicDefinition RIBA_TechnicalDesign

beachtom commented 1 year ago

Just a note to say not every project should adopt these - so we need to have the flexibility for this to be exentsible.

See https://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/Comparison_of_standard_project_plans_used_in_the_construction_industry for some comparisons

AmnaKRDB commented 1 year ago

The permitting_stages have been now related to standards as well using the property aec3po:hasPermittingStage, which is equivalent to dicl:hasStage. the dicstg: has been used to define the list of standards.