search

ActiveState / appdirs

A small Python module for determining appropriate platform-specific dirs, e.g. a "user data dir".
http://pypi.python.org/pypi/appdirs
MIT License
1.05k stars 98 forks source link

Development/maintenance status #79

Open sotte opened 7 years ago

sotte commented 7 years ago

What is the development status of this project? The last commit was on Jul 23, 2015, but there seem to be some interest in this project (issues as well as PRs).

Maybe it's possible to find a new maintainer for this project you guys don't want to keep maintaining it.

Kriskras99 commented 7 years ago

I would love to take over this project. In my fork I have implemented new tests and merged the current PRs. And in the dev branch I have added support for xdg-user-dirs and replaced CSDIL with KNOWNFOLDERID.

zoofood commented 7 years ago

Hi Guys,

I've discussed with the team here at ActiveState and we'll ramp up maintenance again on this shortly. Sorry for the delay.

Cheers,

-JR

sotte commented 7 years ago

Nice to hear that!

Maybe you can integrate @Kriskras99 changes.

Kriskras99 commented 7 years ago

I will open a pull request when the other pull requests are merged or closed, because I depend on some of them.

Kriskras99 commented 7 years ago

@zoofood could you start merging the already open pull requests (Especially #53, #56 and #64)? Then I could open a pull request for a new test framework, and give a more "correct" replacement for CSIDL.

dgentry commented 7 years ago

Hi @zoofood,

Do you know when "shortly" is? If it's going to be more than another week (just over a month since you last posted), maybe you could just add @Kriskras99's as a repo maintainer? If not, maybe we should all consider his stable fork to be the canonical one now. At my company, TwoPoreGuys, we would immediately use #64 and #81.

Thanks, Dennis

zoofood commented 7 years ago

My apologies. The team was very busy, I'm moving things through here myself, kicking it off over the holidays here, but will take a bit of ramp up.

Kriskras99 commented 7 years ago

Nice to hear, as soon as the pull requests are merged, I will squash my commits and open a pull request.

WhyNotHugo commented 7 years ago

TBH, since development has stagnated before (and picking this up again is also going a bit slow), maybe you ought to consider taking up a co-maintainer, so we're sure this doesn't happen again (it also increases trust by users/other devs).

pradyunsg commented 6 years ago

@zoofood Please do consider adding someone as a co-maintainer -- it would help reduce the bus factor here and improve the health of the project as a whole.

pradyunsg commented 5 years ago

@zoofood I'll be happy to be a co-maintainer for this project, if you're willing to add one. :)

jhermann commented 4 years ago

https://jazzband.co/ would be another option. 27 commits since the last release that could be published…

ofek commented 4 years ago

I agree that https://github.com/jazzband seems like the logical home

pradyunsg commented 4 years ago

Dropping in to say that I'm still interested in picking up maintenance for this package.

McSinyx commented 4 years ago

@pradyunsg: I think it's not that the @ActiveState team cannot maintain this, but they are like completely off the grid (sure @zoofood does not seem to visit GitHub very regularly, but there should be at least another team member with write access, or even just some minimal communication). It was really sad to see @ofek pinging for almost two weeks straight. I'll not be surprised to see you dropping the same message next year and still be entirely ignored.

zoofood commented 4 years ago

Hi Gang,

I appreciate everyone's anxiousness/frustration/concern here. I originally took on maintenance as Trent and Srid had moved on and it needed a home and we were rebuilding our team at ActiveState. It has sadly languished at the bottom of my todo list in the last while. It is not any issue with ActiveState per se, we have plenty of community initiatives spread across many language ecosystems (Python/Perl/Go/Tcl) that we are putting time/money into and not the least of which we are building a platform by which the community can put together their own Python runtimes and dependencies, all built from source.

I always planned to get back to this project as I quite enjoy it and want to give back where possible. With that in mind, I am going to work internally at ActiveState to find some resources to get this project back in shape. If we can't put a meaningful effort into this project and get releases out we will hand it off by the end of April.

I have had several offers of help and many good options, thanks to everyone that has reached out.

Thanks.

-JR

ofek commented 4 years ago

@zoofood Any update?

zoofood commented 4 years ago

Hi @ofek, thanks for checking in. Had some hurdles to get it on PyPI, will be resolved this week and the first of several updates will go out to get us current.

pradyunsg commented 4 years ago

goes to https://pypi.org/project/appdirs/

appdirs 1.4.4

Released: May 11, 2020

Hurray! 🎉

ofek commented 4 years ago

@zoofood Are we still considering donating the project?

I see a release happened, which is great! However, the only other development has been merging a shebang line removal and 2 PRs removing names of people who no longer maintain this...

pradyunsg commented 4 years ago

I'm up for picking up the maintenance of this package (my earlier offer to co-maintain still stands) and I'm still interested. I'll also echo the suggestion of making this a part of jazzband to ease the development overhead.

I also recognise that the world is... uhm... going through unprecedented times and making releases of OSS software falling lower in the priority list is OK. It'll still be helpful to know what the state of affairs is.

eukreign commented 4 years ago

I just joined jazzband (in anticipation of this project being moved over there) and thus also support moving this project there.

I have a PR pending on this repo that's been there for a week (and I see dozens others for way longer): https://github.com/ActiveState/appdirs/pull/147

I work on a product which has been using appdirs (https://github.com/lbryio/lbry-sdk) for at least 4 years, so am very invested in continuing to maintain this project, ideally jazzband can adopt it, otherwise I'll have to fork it and contribute to the existing 70 forks (i'd rather not do that).

I can take the lead on this or support someone else here who's been pushing for this before me.

Let's just do something.

ofek commented 4 years ago

Any update?

ofek commented 4 years ago

I guess not?

gaborbernat commented 4 years ago

I always planned to get back to this project as I quite enjoy it and want to give back where possible. With that in mind, I am going to work internally at ActiveState to find some resources to get this project back in shape. If we can't put a meaningful effort into this project and get releases out we will hand it off by the end of April.

I understand that resource availability is an issue. However, considering this I think everyone would benefit if you'd bless 2 more people to maintain besides yourself. 17 pull requests open does not feel like a good place to be. Thanks for your efforts until now but consider offloading some of the work when you get busy with other things.

ofek commented 4 years ago

@zoofood Any progress on this?

pradyunsg commented 4 years ago

Yet-another-nudge.

ofek commented 4 years ago

Any update? @zoofood

pradyunsg commented 3 years ago

nudge

pradyunsg commented 3 years ago

I'm up for picking up the maintenance of this package (my earlier offer to co-maintain still stands) and I'm still interested. I'll also echo the suggestion of making this a part of jazzband to ease the development overhead.

Reiterating that this offer still stands.

ofek commented 3 years ago

Any update? @zoofood

gaborbernat commented 3 years ago

At this point, I'm tempted to fork the project and start maintaining it under a new name 🤔

WhyNotHugo commented 3 years ago

@gaborbernat Looks like there's been a bit of activity in recent weeks here. Might be worth seeing how this moves forward.

ofek commented 3 years ago

@gaborbernat Can you please? We'll switch immediately.

ofek commented 3 years ago

@gaborbernat Did you fork?

gaborbernat commented 3 years ago

@ofek not yet 😊 if you'd want this now you could go-ahead 👍🏻

YariKartoshe4ka commented 3 years ago

I am interesing in this project too and do not mind be maintencer or help it with PRs

gaborbernat commented 3 years ago

For anyone looking we forked the repository to https://github.com/platformdirs/platformdirs 👍

WhyNotHugo commented 3 years ago

Whoops. I've been working on apppaths as a fork. Maybe we should coordinate better, do you think an IRC channel to follow up on direction an alike would make sense?

I'd rather hold on my fork if there's already another -- having two does more damage than harm. I don't honestly have many changes, mostly updating the code to return Path instances rather than str instances.

gaborbernat commented 3 years ago

Feel free to open discussions at https://github.com/platformdirs/platformdirs

WhyNotHugo commented 3 years ago

Looks like issues for that repository are disabled.

ofek commented 3 years ago

I've just enabled them, try now.

elenakrittik commented 1 year ago

☠️

pradyunsg commented 1 year ago

On a different note, we can close this out on the basis that https://github.com/ActiveState/appdirs/commit/8734277956c1df3b85385e6b308e954910533884 has happened.