AdguardTeam / AdGuardDNS

Public DNS resolver that protects you from ad trackers
https://adguard-dns.io/
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
787 stars 62 forks source link

Adguard dns unlimited queries #454

Open ghost opened 2 years ago

ghost commented 2 years ago

Are there any ideas for the future already? For home usage to provide unlimited queries

for free, Or a additional addon for 5/10eur extra a month

its not about if someone reach 10million but its just for a idea Ive seen more people that wants it

ghost commented 2 years ago

I second this...unlimited just gives a sense of no worry about ads. Else telling like 10million queries gives worry like when will it end and ads will popup thus checking the dashboard from time to time wasting time

sjhgvr commented 2 years ago

My 2 cents; there's no such thing as unlimited. There is however something like: "as much as needed".

I'd say your average Joe wouldn't know how many queries he needs. So he wouldn't know if 10 million is enough.

If it was me running this, I'd rebrand it to "unlimited" or "as many queries as you need"

Where the * points to a FUP message, and maybe stating the average user queries, and comparing that to 10 million.

Adguard will know the difference between use and miss-use. So they could just allow for over 10 million for real users and maybe even contact miss-users before 10 million

SHJordan commented 2 years ago

I think 10M is a good start point, hard to hit monthly by an avg house. (3 computers, 5 phones, 2 tvs, 1 xbox) making it "flex" when you reach the 10M mark, like pay 3 extra to cover until the end of the month or just unfilter til the end of the month would be a good way to deal with it. heck... even partner with other brands like quad9 for the missing queries over 10M mark. the dashboard is just too good to let it go.

ghost commented 2 years ago

My 2 cents; there's no such thing as unlimited. There is however something like: "as much as needed".

I'd say your average Joe wouldn't know how many queries he needs. So he wouldn't know if 10 million is enough.

If it was me running this, I'd rebrand it to "unlimited" or "as many queries as you need"

Where the * points to a FUP message, and maybe stating the average user queries, and comparing that to 10 million.

Adguard will know the difference between use and miss-use. So they could just allow for over 10 million for real users and maybe even contact miss-users before 10 million

Yes them saying 10M directly gives fear xD

ghost commented 2 years ago

My 2 cents; there's no such thing as unlimited. There is however something like: "as much as needed".

I'd say your average Joe wouldn't know how many queries he needs. So he wouldn't know if 10 million is enough.

If it was me running this, I'd rebrand it to "unlimited" or "as many queries as you need"

Where the * points to a FUP message, and maybe stating the average user queries, and comparing that to 10 million.

Adguard will know the difference between use and miss-use. So they could just allow for over 10 million for real users and maybe even contact miss-users before 10 million

Its just the same system as nextdns does

sjhgvr commented 2 years ago

My 2 cents; there's no such thing as unlimited. There is however something like: "as much as needed". I'd say your average Joe wouldn't know how many queries he needs. So he wouldn't know if 10 million is enough. If it was me running this, I'd rebrand it to "unlimited" or "as many queries as you need" Where the * points to a FUP message, and maybe stating the average user queries, and comparing that to 10 million. Adguard will know the difference between use and miss-use. So they could just allow for over 10 million for real users and maybe even contact miss-users before 10 million

Its just the same system as nextdns does

So you agree with me?

ghost commented 2 years ago

My 2 cents; there's no such thing as unlimited. There is however something like: "as much as needed". I'd say your average Joe wouldn't know how many queries he needs. So he wouldn't know if 10 million is enough. If it was me running this, I'd rebrand it to "unlimited" or "as many queries as you need" Where the * points to a FUP message, and maybe stating the average user queries, and comparing that to 10 million. Adguard will know the difference between use and miss-use. So they could just allow for over 10 million for real users and maybe even contact miss-users before 10 million

Its just the same system as nextdns does

So you agree with me?

No

ghost commented 1 year ago

Increasing the block TTL to 3600 seconds would drastically reduce your usage as I hardly hit the DNS mark to 5M anytime. Let me tell you that I am covering two households my home in the city where I work and the other where my family lives. Both have 15+ devices, meaning I am covering ~30 devices at a time as I have set the DNS on the router level, and some personal devices I have direct access to so that if something goes wrong, I can change it immediately. Recently I have become mature with the list selection on AdGuard DNS 2.0, and everything works fine for me with the 3600 seconds TTL, but you can start testing with as low as 30 seconds.

It is mid-month, and I am still at 2.3M hits from all my devices and other endpoints with configuration files installed or Private DNS on.

Screenshot 2022-12-14 at 9 59 05 PM

Here under server settings, you can see to set it up for yourself.

Screenshot 2022-12-14 at 10 00 43 PM
gpodder770 commented 1 year ago

I also have several devices and reach 9M within 21 days cause setting ttl to 0 for some reason setting to anything above 10 causes iphone devices to be wonky like will take 2-3 reload...ended up shifting back to nextdns