search

AdguardTeam / AdGuardHome

Network-wide ads & trackers blocking DNS server
https://adguard.com/adguard-home.html
GNU General Public License v3.0
23.86k stars 1.75k forks source link

canyoublockit.com vs. AdGuardHome v0.104.3 #2756

Closed tackynugget closed 3 years ago

tackynugget commented 3 years ago

Expected Behavior

Block ads and pass ad-blocking tests.

Actual Behavior

Generally blocks ads, but does not perform well against canyoublockit.com and other ad-blocking test sites.

Screenshots

Screenshot: [Screen Shot 2021-02-24 at 10 44 00 PM](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/12820826/109104594-e076a580-76f1-11eb-8536-883829662ce8.png)

Additional Information

AdGuardHome + AdGuard Chrome Browser extension seems to pass the canyoublockit.com test. But AdGuardHome on its own does not.

bbartlomiej commented 3 years ago

This depends heavily on the blocklists you use. I tried your canyoublockit.com link and on both basic and extreme test I don't see advertisements. AdBlockHome + uBlock Origin

uservictor commented 3 years ago

On second test "eXtreme Test" for DNS based AdBlockers like AGH it works fine for me.

No ads and banners, I use AGH SDNS, Adaway, Spam404 and NoCoin list.

tackynugget commented 3 years ago

Thanks for the feedback.

@bbartlomiej I couldn't find a ublock origin list. It looks like a similar utility to AdGuardHome. Is there a ublock origin list somewhere that I'm missing?

@uservictor I appear to be using the same lists except for SDNS. Screen Shot 2021-02-24 at 10 44 00 PM

uservictor commented 3 years ago

SDNS is the default AGH DNS list, on the "first" test like your picture i see the same pictures. The other test doesnt show any ad.

You can see ads that are not in the list you use, this has nothing to do with AGH, as its function is "just" to check if an requested url is on the blacklist that you use or not. If there is an match it will be blocked.

tackynugget commented 3 years ago

@uservictor Understood.

Is there a Ublock origin list or a better way to consolidate these lists?

I think I read about blocking Google DNS at the firewall level to stop those ads too.

uservictor commented 3 years ago

I am not sure if there is any ad shown on this page (while using AGH) or if those pictures are just examples.

When I click on those pitures or look on the url of it, all redirects to the main site "canyoublockit.com" if they are ads they should have some ad related url (googleads.com for example).

You can disable all ad blockers and clear cache, then test in on the site. As far I can say the filterlists block it all and the pictures are no ads.