search

AdoptOpenJDK / TSC

The AdoptOpenJDK Technical Steering Committee - Also acts as the knowledge portal for the Adopt OpenJDK GitHub projects
70 stars 33 forks source link

AdoptOpenJDK compatible with TCK #187

Closed Jan-Pleva closed 3 years ago

Jan-Pleva commented 3 years ago

Hello, I have question, why AdoptOpenJDK is still not compatible with TCK (Java SE Technology Compatibility Kit )? We would like to use AdoptOpenJDK for Liferay, but there is requirement TCK compatibility.

https://help.liferay.com/hc/en-us/articles/360028982631-Liferay-DXP-7-2-Compatibility-Matrix

@AdoptOpenJDK/tsc please can somebody +1 this request?

aahlenst commented 3 years ago

Oracle does not permit claiming compatibility with the TCK without running the binaries through the TCK. We are not allowed to run the TCK on our binaries.

However, I'd be suprised if Liferay doesn't work flawlessly with AdoptOpenJDK.

Eclipse Adoptium will only provide TCK-certified binaries (see https://projects.eclipse.org/projects/adoptium/governance). There is no ETA for binaries released by Eclipse Adoptium

tellison commented 3 years ago

@Jan-Pleva the reason that AdoptOpenJDK builds are not tested with the TCK is described on our website here (https://adoptopenjdk.net/quality.html#jck).

As part of our move to Eclipse we have been working with the Eclipse Foundation for them to become licensees of the TCK.

Jan-Pleva commented 3 years ago

@aahlenst The problem is that if we will run Liferay on Adopt and some problem will appear, Liferay will not give us support, because in their requirements was TCK compatibility... :/

@tellison Of course I read that website, but it still not clear to me, why Zulu or Corretto have already TCK and Adopt don't. Is there technical problem? political? finance? priority? or why?

tellison commented 3 years ago

Not sure I can state it any more clearly than:

the London Jamocha Community CIC (aka LJC) has not been able to reach an agreement with Oracle to use the Java SE Technology Compatibility Kit (TCK) under the terms of the OpenJDK Community TCK License Agreement (OCTLA)

as I say, the Eclipse Foundation is now working with Oracle on acquiring a license to their tests.

If Liferay have that as a requirement for support then you will have to discuss that with Liferay.

Jan-Pleva commented 3 years ago

@tellison ok. Thank you. Hopefully it won't take too long. I'll check the status after a while.

vijaya-lakshmi-venkatraman commented 1 year ago

Hi I still see the below in their website

the London Jamocha Community CIC (aka LJC) has not been able to reach an agreement with Oracle to use the Java SE Technology Compatibility Kit (TCK) under the terms of the OpenJDK Community TCK License Agreement (OCTLA)

however, I can also see in this link that Temurin Binaries will pass Java SE TCK & AQAVit.

So can I assume that AdoptiumJDK is TCK compliant now?

karianna commented 1 year ago

@vijaya-lakshmi-venkatraman We have moved to adoptium.net as Eclipse Temurin builds which are TCK compliance yes.